All latest updates
An outbreak of yellow fever in Angola could go global
An unwelcome resurgence
YELLOW FEVER occupies a strange place on the spectrum of infectious
tropical diseases. Not as important as malaria. Not as terrifying as
Ebola. Not as revolting as elephantiasis. Yet it is a grave illness,
incurable once contracted. It kills 80,000 Africans a year. And that is a
scandal, both because it can be prevented by a single inoculation and
also because yellow fever risks spreading to Asia, where it has never
before taken hold.
This is the background to the latest epidemic of the disease, in
Angola. Since December, nearly 300 deaths from yellow fever have been
reported there, as well as 2,000 suspected cases that were not fatal.
Set against 80,000 deaths, this might not sound like many but experience
suggests that, for each case brought to the authorities’ attention in a
country where health care is as fragmentary as it is in Angola, between
50 and 500 probably go unreported.
Yellow fever is spread by Aedes aegypti, the mosquito that
also carries dengue and Zika. Its early symptoms—elevated temperature,
nausea, vomiting and muscle pain—are reasonably mild and usually last
only a few days. In about 15% of cases, however, the disease later
returns with a vengeance. Patients experience severe abdominal pain,
become jaundiced and bleed internally and from their eyes, mouth and
nose. About half of these people die.
The UN and the World Health Organisation (WHO) have shipped 9m doses
of vaccine to the country, enough for about a third of the population.
But that is around a fifth of all the vaccine held worldwide at any one
time. If the epidemic spreads, stocks will rapidly run out.
And spread it might. Almost 6m people in Luanda, Angola’s capital,
should now be immune, and the number of Angolan cases being reported to
the WHO has indeed dipped in recent weeks. Yet vaccination rates outside
Luanda remain low, and the efforts have not stopped the disease from
crossing borders.
Laboratory analyses have linked a few cases in Kenya to the Angolan
outbreak. More worrying is the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). On
May 2nd the WHO reported 453 suspected cases of the disease there,
including some in the capital, Kinshasa. Less than 30% of the country’s
population was thought to have been vaccinated before today’s outbreak. A
booming trade in forged vaccination certificates could also let
infected people slip past border checkpoints from Angola into Zambia and
Namibia, which reported its first case on April 28th.
The best way to contain the disease now is to vaccinate all those at
risk as soon as possible. Every day increases the chance that one of the
thousands of Asian workers in Angola will carry the disease home,
sparking an outbreak on a continent that has yet to experience one.
Deployment of the vaccine in all African countries where yellow fever
is endemic could slash the number of cases. The yellow-fever
initiative, which is led by WHO and UNICEF and funded by GAVI, an
international public-private alliance that provides vaccines to poor
countries, aims to cover the continent by 2020, at a cost of $300m. More
than 100m people have been vaccinated since it started in 2007. With
more funding, it might have averted this outbreak: Angola was not among
the 12 countries that were considered most susceptible to the disease.
Production of yellow-fever vaccine has increased in the past five
years, but it would be difficult to raise further. It has only four
sources: Sanofi Pasteur, a French pharmaceutical company, and institutes
in Brazil, Senegal and Russia. “That leaves us in a very vulnerable
position,” says Peter Piot, the director of the London School of Hygiene
and Tropical Medicine. If yellow fever did spread to Asia, he says,
then the numbers at immediate risk would rise from tens of millions to
100m or more.
The world’s emergency stockpile of 11m doses, which is held on top of
normal supply to enable a rapid response to outbreaks, is already being
depleted to control the one in Africa. If the disease takes hold in
Asia, says William Perea of the WHO, there would be little choice but to
limit inoculations to a fifth of a standard dose so as to make supplies
of the vaccine stretch further. Small studies give reason to hope that
this would be enough to protect adults, but the efficacy of a low dose
for children is unknown.
Ill winds
International trade and migration mean
that the chances of yellow fever spreading to Asia are higher than ever
before, warns John Woodall of the Programme for Monitoring Emerging
Diseases, an online-alert service. Cool weather has meant that up till
now there have been few mosquitoes in China to spread the disease. Even
so, the country has already reported its first 11 cases, and summer is
approaching. All those diagnosed had returned from Angola, home to an
estimated 100,000 Chinese workers.
Once yellow fever is established in a tropical country, it is nigh
impossible to eradicate. Monkeys infected by the virus act as a
reservoir for the disease. People who travel to the jungle can carry it
back to towns and cities, where mosquitoes quickly breed—A. aegypti lays its eggs in standing water, meaning that even a discarded food tin could be a breeding ground.
Why Asia has never had a large outbreak of yellow fever is something of a mystery. A. aegypti is
found across much of Southern Asia, and the continent’s jungles have
monkeys that would seem an ideal reservoir for the disease. One
possibility is that antibodies against dengue, a related disease,
partially protect survivors against yellow fever. A second is that the
Asian type of A. aegypti may be less able to carry the virus
than its African cousin. But it is not immune. The fear is that a
traveller who has returned from Africa with yellow fever will be bitten
by an indigenous mosquito, which then spreads the disease.
America, which has not had an outbreak in more than a century, is at
risk, too. Yellow fever used to be common there: Philadelphia suffered
one of the country’s worst outbreaks in 1793, when the disease killed
5,000 people, then about a tenth of the city’s population. In New
Orleans in 1853, nearly 8,000 died. The port cities of Europe also
suffered outbreaks: one in Barcelona in 1821 killed thousands.
But by the middle of the 20th century yellow fever was gone from the
northern hemisphere, as fumigation was used to beat the mosquito back.
In Cuba the same remedy, and more effective sanitation, also removed the
source of many of America’s epidemics. Vaccination campaigns in
France’s West African colonies between 1933 and 1961 caused yellow fever
virtually to disappear from the continent—until decolonisation, when
vaccination rates plummeted and the disease reappeared.
In South America yellow fever was once kept at bay by
mosquito-control measures in cities. But international arrivals add to
the threat caused by travellers returning from remote jungle areas, in
some of which it is endemic. For many places now free of the disease, a
few infected visitors at the height of summer, and some bad luck, could
mean its unwelcome return.
This is the background to the latest epidemic of the disease, in Angola. Since December, nearly 300 deaths from yellow fever have been reported there, as well as 2,000 suspected cases that were not fatal. Set against 80,000 deaths, this might not sound like many but experience suggests that, for each case brought to the authorities’ attention in a country where health care is as fragmentary as it is in Angola, between 50 and 500 probably go unreported.
Yellow fever is spread by Aedes aegypti, the mosquito that also carries dengue and Zika. Its early symptoms—elevated temperature, nausea, vomiting and muscle pain—are reasonably mild and usually last only a few days. In about 15% of cases, however, the disease later returns with a vengeance. Patients experience severe abdominal pain, become jaundiced and bleed internally and from their eyes, mouth and nose. About half of these people die.
And spread it might. Almost 6m people in Luanda, Angola’s capital, should now be immune, and the number of Angolan cases being reported to the WHO has indeed dipped in recent weeks. Yet vaccination rates outside Luanda remain low, and the efforts have not stopped the disease from crossing borders.
Laboratory analyses have linked a few cases in Kenya to the Angolan outbreak. More worrying is the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). On May 2nd the WHO reported 453 suspected cases of the disease there, including some in the capital, Kinshasa. Less than 30% of the country’s population was thought to have been vaccinated before today’s outbreak. A booming trade in forged vaccination certificates could also let infected people slip past border checkpoints from Angola into Zambia and Namibia, which reported its first case on April 28th.
The best way to contain the disease now is to vaccinate all those at risk as soon as possible. Every day increases the chance that one of the thousands of Asian workers in Angola will carry the disease home, sparking an outbreak on a continent that has yet to experience one.
Deployment of the vaccine in all African countries where yellow fever is endemic could slash the number of cases. The yellow-fever initiative, which is led by WHO and UNICEF and funded by GAVI, an international public-private alliance that provides vaccines to poor countries, aims to cover the continent by 2020, at a cost of $300m. More than 100m people have been vaccinated since it started in 2007. With more funding, it might have averted this outbreak: Angola was not among the 12 countries that were considered most susceptible to the disease.
Production of yellow-fever vaccine has increased in the past five years, but it would be difficult to raise further. It has only four sources: Sanofi Pasteur, a French pharmaceutical company, and institutes in Brazil, Senegal and Russia. “That leaves us in a very vulnerable position,” says Peter Piot, the director of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. If yellow fever did spread to Asia, he says, then the numbers at immediate risk would rise from tens of millions to 100m or more.
The world’s emergency stockpile of 11m doses, which is held on top of normal supply to enable a rapid response to outbreaks, is already being depleted to control the one in Africa. If the disease takes hold in Asia, says William Perea of the WHO, there would be little choice but to limit inoculations to a fifth of a standard dose so as to make supplies of the vaccine stretch further. Small studies give reason to hope that this would be enough to protect adults, but the efficacy of a low dose for children is unknown.
Ill winds
International trade and migration mean that the chances of yellow fever spreading to Asia are higher than ever before, warns John Woodall of the Programme for Monitoring Emerging Diseases, an online-alert service. Cool weather has meant that up till now there have been few mosquitoes in China to spread the disease. Even so, the country has already reported its first 11 cases, and summer is approaching. All those diagnosed had returned from Angola, home to an estimated 100,000 Chinese workers.
Once yellow fever is established in a tropical country, it is nigh impossible to eradicate. Monkeys infected by the virus act as a reservoir for the disease. People who travel to the jungle can carry it back to towns and cities, where mosquitoes quickly breed—A. aegypti lays its eggs in standing water, meaning that even a discarded food tin could be a breeding ground.
Why Asia has never had a large outbreak of yellow fever is something of a mystery. A. aegypti is found across much of Southern Asia, and the continent’s jungles have monkeys that would seem an ideal reservoir for the disease. One possibility is that antibodies against dengue, a related disease, partially protect survivors against yellow fever. A second is that the Asian type of A. aegypti may be less able to carry the virus than its African cousin. But it is not immune. The fear is that a traveller who has returned from Africa with yellow fever will be bitten by an indigenous mosquito, which then spreads the disease.
America, which has not had an outbreak in more than a century, is at risk, too. Yellow fever used to be common there: Philadelphia suffered one of the country’s worst outbreaks in 1793, when the disease killed 5,000 people, then about a tenth of the city’s population. In New Orleans in 1853, nearly 8,000 died. The port cities of Europe also suffered outbreaks: one in Barcelona in 1821 killed thousands.
But by the middle of the 20th century yellow fever was gone from the northern hemisphere, as fumigation was used to beat the mosquito back. In Cuba the same remedy, and more effective sanitation, also removed the source of many of America’s epidemics. Vaccination campaigns in France’s West African colonies between 1933 and 1961 caused yellow fever virtually to disappear from the continent—until decolonisation, when vaccination rates plummeted and the disease reappeared.
In South America yellow fever was once kept at bay by mosquito-control measures in cities. But international arrivals add to the threat caused by travellers returning from remote jungle areas, in some of which it is endemic. For many places now free of the disease, a few infected visitors at the height of summer, and some bad luck, could mean its unwelcome return.
No comments:
Post a Comment