IT IS easy to forget that adultery was a crime in Spain until 1978;
or that in America, where gay marriage is allowed by 37 states and may
soon be extended to all others by the Supreme Court, the last
anti-sodomy law was struck down only in 2003. Yet, although most Western
governments no longer try to dictate how consenting adults have sex,
the state still stands in the way of their choices about death. An
increasing number of people—and this newspaper—believe that is wrong.
The argument is over the right to die with a doctor’s help at the
time and in the manner of your own choosing. As yet only a handful of
European countries, Colombia and five American states allow some form of
doctor-assisted dying. But draft bills, ballot initiatives and court
cases are progressing in 20 more states and several other countries (see
article).
In Canada the Supreme Court recently struck down a ban on helping
patients to die; its ruling will take effect next year. In the coming
months bills will go before parliaments in Britain and Germany.
The idea fills its critics with dismay. For some, the argument is
moral and absolute. Deliberately ending a human life is wrong, because
life is sacred and the endurance of suffering confers its own dignity.
For others, the legalisation of doctor-assisted dying is the first step
on a slippery slope where the vulnerable are threatened and where
premature death becomes a cheap alternative to palliative care.
These views are deeply held and deserve to be taken seriously. But
liberty and autonomy are sources of human dignity, too. Both add to the
value of a life. In a secular society, it is odd to buttress the
sanctity of life in the abstract by subjecting a lot of particular lives
to unbearable pain, misery and suffering. And evidence from places that
have allowed assisted dying suggests that there is no slippery slope
towards widespread euthanasia. In fact, the evidence leads to the
conclusion that most of the schemes for assisted dying should be bolder.
Nothing is hurt, nothing is lost
The popular desire for assisted dying is beyond question
. The Economist
asked Ipsos MORI to survey people in 15 countries on whether doctors
should be allowed to help patients to die, and if so, how and when.
Russia and Poland are against, but we find strong support across America
and western Europe for allowing doctors to prescribe lethal drugs to
patients with terminal diseases. In 11 out of the 15 countries we
surveyed, most people favoured extending doctor-assisted dying to
patients who are in great physical suffering but not close to death.
No wonder that, just as adultery existed in Spain before 1978, so too
many doctors help their patients die even if the law bans them from
doing so. Usually this is by withdrawing treatment or administering
pain-relief in lethal doses. Often doctors act after talking to patients
and their relatives. Occasionally, when doctors overstep the mark, they
are investigated, though rarely charged. Some people welcome this fudge
because it establishes limits to doctor-assisted dying without the need
to articulate the difficult moral choices this involves.
But this approach is unethical and unworkable. It is unethical
because an explicit choice that should lie with the patient is wholly in
the hands of a doctor. It is hypocritical because society is pretending
to shun doctor-assisted dying while tacitly condoning it without
safeguards. What may turn out to be more important, this system is also
becoming impractical. Most deaths now take place in hospital, under
teams of doctors who are working with closer legal and professional
oversight. Death by nods and winks is no good.
Better is to face the arguments. One fear is that assisted dying will
be foisted on vulnerable patients, bullied by rogue doctors, grasping
relatives, miserly insurers or a cash-strapped state. Experience in
Oregon, which has had a law since 1997, suggests otherwise. Those who
choose assisted suicide are in fact well-educated, insured and receiving
palliative care. They are motivated by pain, as well as the desire to
preserve their own dignity, autonomy and pleasure in life.
Another fear is that assisted dying will downgrade care. But Belgium
and Holland have some of the best palliative care in Europe. Surveys
show that doctors are as trusted in countries with assisted dying as
they are in those without. And there are scant signs of a slippery
slope. In Oregon only 1,327 people have received lethal medicine—and
just two-thirds of those have used it to take their lives. Assisted
dying now accounts for about 3% of deaths in the Netherlands—a large
number—but this is less a rush to assisted dying than the coming to
light of an unspoken tradition in which doctors quietly brought their
patients’ lives to an end.
Wear no forced air of solemnity or sorrow
How, then, should assisted dying work? For many the model is Oregon’s
Death with Dignity Act. It allows (but does not oblige) doctors to
prescribe lethal drugs to patients with less than six months to live who
ask for them, if a second doctor agrees. There is a cooling-off period
of 15 days.
We would go further. Oregon insists that the lethal dose is
self-administered, to avoid voluntary euthanasia. To the patient the
moral distinction between taking a pill and asking for an injection is
slight. But the practical consequence of this stricture is to prevent
those who are incapacitated from being granted help to die. Not
surprisingly, some of the fiercest campaigners for doctor-assisted dying
suffer from ailments such as motor neurone disease, which causes
progressive paralysis. They want to know that when they are
incapacitated, they will be granted help to die, if that is their wish.
Allowing doctors to administer the drugs would ensure this.
Oregon’s law covers only conditions that are terminal. Again, that is
too rigid. The criterion for assisting dying should be a patient’s
assessment of his suffering, not the nature of his illness. Some
activists for the rights of the disabled regard the idea that death
could be better than a chronic condition as tantamount to declaring
disabled people to be of lesser worth. We regard it as an expression of
their autonomy. So do many disabled people. Stephen Hawking has
described keeping someone alive against his wishes as the “ultimate
indignity”.
One exception to this distinction should be children. The decision of
whether to endure chronic conditions should be left until adulthood.
But, as with adults, children facing imminent death from terminal
diseases should, in consultation with their parents and doctors, have
the right to be spared their last agonising hours.
The hardest question is whether doctor-assisted dying should be
available for those in mental anguish. No one wants to make suicide
easier for the depressed: many will recover and enjoy life again. But
mental pain is as real as physical pain, even though it is harder for
onlookers to gauge. And even among the terminally ill, the suffering
that causes some to seek a quicker death may not be physical.
Doctor-assisted death on grounds of mental suffering should therefore be
allowed.
Because patients’ judgments may be ill-informed and states of mind
can change, especially among the mentally ill, society should help
people to die only when safeguards are in place. These should include
mandatory counselling about alternatives, such as pain relief,
psychotherapy and palliative care; a waiting period, to ensure that the
intention is enduring; and a face-to-face consultation with a second,
independent medical expert to confirm the patient’s prognosis and
capacity. In cases of mental suffering the safeguards should be
especially strong.
The most determined people do not always choose wisely, no matter how
well they are counselled. But it would be wrong to deny everyone the
right to assisted death for this reason alone. Competent adults are
allowed to make other momentous, irrevocable choices: to undergo a sex
change or to have an abortion. People deserve the same control over
their own death. Instead of dying in intensive care under bright lights
and among strangers, people should be able to end their lives when they
are ready, surrounded by those they love.