Ed Miliband has accused David
Cameron and other world leaders of failing to stand by Libya,
contributing in part to the crisis in the Mediterranean.
The
Labour leader said the UK had repeated the same mistakes "in
post-conflict planning" for Libya as were made in Iraq and the current
refugee situation should have been anticipated.
Conservatives denounced the remarks. Mr Cameron called them "ill-judged".
But Mr Miliband rejected claims he had politicised the issue as "nonsense".
Setting
out his foreign policy priorities in a speech in London, Mr Miliband
also pledged to rebuild the UK's international standing, claiming Mr
Cameron had presided over the "biggest loss of influence in a
generation" and placed the UK's future in the European Union in doubt.
The
BBC's assistant political editor Norman Smith said Labour were making
clear that they were not blaming the prime minister for the recent
deaths in the Mediterranean.
But Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg said
any suggestion of "political point-scoring" on the back of a "total
human tragedy" was "pretty distasteful".
'Avoidable'
Mr
Miliband voted in favour of UN authorised air strikes against former
Libyan leader Muammar al-Gaddafi in 2011, designed to stop the slaughter
of Libyan civilians in Benghazi.
The intervention led to the collapse of the Gaddafi regime but the country has descended into chaos since then.
An
estimated 800 people died when their boats sank off the Libyan coast on
Sunday while more than 35,000 people are thought to have crossed from
Africa to Europe this year, many of them being transited through Libya
and departing from there.
In a speech in London, the Labour leader suggested that the UK and the wider international community had let Libya down. Analysis by Peter Hunt, Labour campaign correspondent
It was meant to be about Ed Miliband's vision beyond the purely domestic.
It
became, in part, a row over whether or not he was accusing David
Cameron of being in some way culpable for the deaths of migrants in the
Mediterranean.
First there were the briefings and the counter-briefings by the unelected spin doctors.
Then
those seeking elected office weighed in, with Tory representatives
accusing Mr Miliband of being absolutely offensive; and their Labour
opponents insisting the other side was manufacturing a row.
And all this before the man who wants to govern had uttered a word.
And all because of 29 words in bold in a Labour briefing document.
For the Tories, it's been an opportunity, once again, to question whether Ed Miliband has what it takes to be prime minister.
For Labour, it's been a chance to try and portray their leader as a man who'll be at ease representing the UK abroad.
And
for the electorate, the speech and the spat have been a reminder that
the challenges of Europe, migrants and the so-called Islamic State await
whoever occupies No 10 once voters have delivered their verdict. "David
Cameron was wrong to assume that Libya was a country whose institutions
could be left to evolve and transform on their own," he said.
"The tragedy is that this could have been anticipated. It should have been avoided.
"And
Britain could have played its part in ensuring the international
community stood by the people of Libya in practice rather than standing
behind the unfounded hopes of potential progress only in principle."
A
briefing note released by Labour ahead of the speech sparked a row
after it suggested Mr Miliband would say the refugee crisis and tragic
scenes in the Mediterranean this week were in part a direct result of
the failure of post-conflict planning for Libya.
Asked after his speech whether he was directly pinning the blame on
Mr Cameron, Mr Miliband said the Conservatives were trying to "whip up a
storm" and his position was "absolutely clear".
"As far as what
is happening with the tragic scenes of people drowning in the
Mediterranean, that is the result of the people traffickers.
"But
nobody can disagree with the idea that the failure of post-conflict
planning has been responsible for some of the situation we see in Libya
and indeed people then fleeing."
'Direct blame'
He
was later asked during a BBC Radio 1 Newsbeat event why he had not
asked about Libya during Prime Minister's Questions for four years. Mr
Miliband said he had raised the issue in the Commons in February.
Speaking
on a campaign visit to Lincoln, Mr Cameron said leaders needed to
demonstrate "clarity, consistency and strength" in the face of a
"dangerous and uncertain world".
On Thursday, Mr Cameron pledged UK military assets to boost search
and rescue efforts in the Mediterranean after an emergency EU summit, in
which leaders agreed to treble funding for search and rescue efforts.
The
EU will also look at ways to capture and destroy smugglers' boats and
deploy immigration officers to non-EU countries, officials said.
The
boost in funding to some €120m (£86m) brings spending back up to about
the level of Mare Nostrum, an Italian-run search-and-rescue operation
that was cancelled last year.
Speaking on BBC Radio 5 live, Mr Clegg said a considerable amount of
thought had gone into how to stabilise Libya after Gaddafi's fall,
contrasting this with the aftermath of the 2003 Iraq invasion for which
he said there had been "no planning at all".
But he added: "At the end of the day the future of Libya is in the hands of the Libyan people".
'No lecture'
Setting
out his foreign policy vision, Mr Miliband said he would take a
hard-headed approach to foreign intervention, saying it should only
happen as a "last resort" and with the support of regional allies.
"Saying something needs to be done is not a sufficient guide to foreign policy," he said.
However, he did not rule out extending sanctions on Russia for its actions in Ukraine, saying the EU had been too slow to act.
Former
foreign secretary William Hague said Mr Miliband "cannot come to
foreign policy with some ill-judged and opportunistic remarks after five
years of saying very little at all".
The Conservatives say they
will "ensure Britain is a major player on the world stage", exerting
diplomatic influence through its bilateral alliances and its membership
of the UN Security Council and the G7.
In other election news:
Mr Cameron says proposals for "English votes for English laws" would be in place for the first Budget of a Conservative government
The Liberal Democrats say either an "ideologically-driven single party government" or an "unstable" alliance would put the economy at risk
HSBC says it is considering whether to move its global headquarters out of London
Ed Miliband has said Labour will "change the way the country is run and who it is run for" as he launched the party's election manifesto.
Saying
he had been tested as opposition leader and was "ready" for power, Mr
Miliband said Labour would be a "party of change and responsibility".
He ruled out a "shopping list of proposals", guaranteeing all policies would require no extra borrowing.
But PM David Cameron accused Mr Miliband of trying to "con" the public.
The 86-page manifesto, which is 20,421 words long, sets out Labour's main policy pledges, including:
Raising the minimum wage to more than £8 by the end of 2019
A one-year freeze in rail fares, costing £200m, paid for by delaying upgrades to the A27 and A358 trunk roads
Twenty-five hours of childcare for
working parents of three and four-year olds and a new right to pre and
after-school help, paid for by rise in bank levy
Freezing gas and electricity bills until 2017, so they can only fall not rise
A £2.5bn fund for the NHS paid for largely by a mansion tax on properties valued at over £2m
Scrapping winter fuel payments for the richest pensioners, capping child benefit rises and protecting tax credits
A 50p tax rate on incomes over £150,000 a year and abolishing non-dom status. Rises in VAT and national insurance ruled out
A cut in university tuition fees from £9,000 to £6,000
Speaking in Manchester, Mr Miliband said the first page of
Labour's manifesto "sets out a vow to protect our nation's finances; a
clear commitment that every policy... is paid for without a single penny
of extra borrowing".
Labour would not promise anything it could
not fund, he said, contrasting this with the Conservatives which he
described as the "party of sums that do not add up and commitments that
cannot be kept".
He added: "The plan we lay before you is no less ambitious because we live in a time of scarcity.
"It
is more ambitious because it starts from a clear commitment to balance
the books and more ambitious because it does not stop there.
"It meets the scale of the challenges we face today with not one policy funded by extra borrowing."
'Tested'
Mr
Miliband said Labour would put the interests of working people ahead of
vested commercial interests, promising to raise the minimum wage to
more than £8 by 2020 and requiring the wealthiest in society to pay more
in tax.
He said he would not seek to "carry on from where the
last Labour government left off" but would "seek to solve the challenges
of our time".
Addressing criticism of his leadership and
suitability to be prime minister, which the Conservatives have made an
election issue, he said: "Over the last four-and-a-half years, I have
been tested.
"It is right that I have been tested for the privilege of leading this country.
"I am ready. Ready to put an end to the tired old idea that as long as we look after the rich and powerful we will all be OK.
"Ready to put into practice the truth that it is only when working people succeed, that Britain succeeds."
Responsibility "triple lock":
fully funded manifesto, cut the deficit every year, balance the books as
soon as possible in next Parliament
Extra £2.5bn for NHS, largely paid for by a mansion tax on properties valued at over £2m
Raise minimum wage to more than £8ph by 2019
No rise in VAT, NI or basic and higher rates of income tax
Access to wraparound childcare for parents of primary school children
Freeze energy bills until 2017 and give energy regulator new powers to cut bills this winter
But Mr Cameron told BBC Radio Newcastle: "When people hear Ed
Miliband today they will think this is not a conversion to
responsibility. It is not a conversion, it is a con."
In other election news on Monday:
The Liberal Democrats launch a "five-point plan",
aimed at consumers and commuters, with proposals such as to end
above-inflation rail fare rises and force energy firms to allow
customers to change supplier within 24 hours
One hundred small business owners,
some of which used to support Labour, have written a letter to the Sun
saying they intend to vote Tory
The Green Party calls for a "review" of horse and greyhound racing as it launches a national poster campaign
Ed Miliband and Nigel Farage will be at opposite ends of the platform during the BBC's election debate on Thursday
A new ICM poll gives the Conservatives a six-point lead over Labour while YouGov's latest poll puts Labour three points ahead
With political parties under increasing pressure to explain how
they will fund their pledges, the Institute for Fiscal Studies
complained on Sunday that they were making "lots of promises" without
producing much detail on how to deliver them.
Carl Emmerson, the IFS deputy director, said Labour had not indicated
whether cuts would be made to police, defence or local government
budgets to balance the books.
Labour has said it would "do what it takes" to support the NHS but would not make any funding promises which could not be met.
It
is guaranteeing that every policy is paid for without additional
borrowing through a "budget responsibility lock", which would also
require all the major parties to have their tax and spending plans
audited by the independent Office for Budget Responsibility before a
general election. Analysis by political editor Nick Robinson
Ed Miliband's "mission" as your prime minister would, he said, be simply summed up: "I will always stand up for you."
It was one of the most powerful speeches I've seen him make.
It
was, though, the front page of the manifesto with its "Budget
Responsibility Commitment" and "clear vow to protect our nation's
finances" which revealed his greatest fear. How can he convince voters
so soon after the Great Crash of 2008 to put Labour in charge of the
economy again?
He promises a "triple lock ….everything in this
manifesto is funded. The deficit will be cut every year. The books will
be balanced and the national debt will be falling."
The language is new. The prominence it's being given is new too and a
stark contrast with that last big speech Ed Miliband made in
Manchester, at the Labour Party conference, when he "forgot the
deficit". The content is not though. Read Nick's blog in full. Both the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats have pledged to eliminate the £90bn annual deficit by 2017/18.
However,
while Labour promises to cut borrowing during every year of the coming
Parliament, the party offers no deadline, saying it would commit to
achieving a budget surplus on current spending "as soon as possible"
between 2015 and 2020.
Labour's rivals said its track record was
one of economic mismanagement, with Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg likening
Labour's borrowing pledge to "an alcoholic, who drinks a bottle of vodka
every day, claiming they have no plans for additional vodka".
UKIP
leader Nigel Farage said there was no detail about how the deficit
would be cut, while the SNP's Nicola Sturgeon said Scotland would see
further budget cuts under Labour.
Employers group the CBI welcomed
Labour's focus on fiscal responsibility but said its proposed
interventions in markets such as energy were worrying.
The Conservatives and Greens are due to launch their manifestos on Tuesday, followed later this week by the Lib Dems and UKIP.
Several manifesto pledges made in 2010, including a Conservative plan to
raise the inheritance tax threshold and a Lib Dem commitment for a £2m
"mansion tax", did not make it into the coalition programme the two
parties agreed on after the two parties went into government together.
The Conservatives are standing by an attack on Ed Miliband that Labour said had dragged politics "into the gutter".
Defence
Secretary Michael Fallon said Mr Miliband had "stabbed his own brother
in the back" to lead Labour and was now "willing to stab the UK in the
back" by doing a deal on Trident with the SNP "to become PM".
Mr Miliband said the defence secretary had demeaned himself and his office.
But Prime Minister David Cameron said Mr Fallon was "absolutely right".
In other election news:
Labour pledged teenagers would be guaranteed face-to-face individual careers advice if the party is in government
SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon said her party would only press for another independence referendum if something material changed
A Plaid Cymru candidate at the centre of a Nazi slur row admitted he has had a "baptism of fire"
UKIP admitted it was "lagging" behind with women voters and that the party sometimes resembles a "rugby club on tour"
"This is the day the election campaign got personal", said BBC deputy political editor James Landale.
"The Conservatives believe that focusing on Ed Miliband's character
and a potential Labour-SNP deal will win them votes in England.
"But
Labour reckon that playing politics with decisions taken about national
defence will backfire and ultimately cost the Tories votes."
The Conservatives and Labour are both committed to replacing the
ageing Trident system - Britain's continuous at-sea nuclear submarine
force.
But the SNP - which has said it would work with Labour in
order to keep the Conservatives out of government after the 7 May
general election - opposes renewing Trident and calls the issue a "red
line".
Mr Fallon suggested the nuclear weapons system could be at
risk if Labour won and did a "grubby deal" with the SNP "to get into
Downing Street" - something denied by Labour.
His comments were also criticised by the Lib Dems and UKIP.
But Mr Cameron said Mr Miliband was "playing fast and loose" with Britain's security.
"I
think that is a really serious issue and that's why Michael Fallon is
absolutely right this and, yes, raise it in a pretty frank way as he did
today," he added.
Chancellor George Osborne and Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith also agreed with the defence secretary.
Lib
Dem leader Nick Clegg described it as "really nasty language" while his
colleague Vince Cable told the BBC it was an "appalling way to conduct
the debate".
Hitting back, Mr Miliband said: "Michael Fallon is a decent man. But
today I think he has demeaned himself and he has demeaned his office.
National security is too important to play politics with."
He said
Mr Cameron had "nothing positive to say about the future of the
country": "He sends out his minions like Michael Fallon to engage in
desperate smears. I think Conservatives today, decent Conservatives
right across our country... will say 'come on, we're better than this
kind of politics'."
Asked if had gone too far, Mr Fallon told the
BBC it was an "issue of trust and of leadership" and denied the comments
were a misjudgement on his part.
Labour has suggested the
possibility of reducing the number of submarines from four to three if a
continuous deterrent could be maintained, although Mr Miliband said
their position at the moment was to stick with four.
The Liberal Democrats favour cutting to three, saying the existing system was designed for the Cold War era.
SNP
Leader - and Scotland's First Minister - Nicola Sturgeon said any
formal arrangement between the SNP and Labour would require a commitment
not to renew Trident. Otherwise she said the party would "vote on a
case-by-case basis and we will never vote for anything that's about
renewing Trident".
Ed Miliband and David Cameron
launched attacks on each other's character in angry Commons exchanges
over televised election debates.
The Labour leader accused the PM
of "chickening out" of a debate with him, saying: "Like all bullies,
when the heat is really on he runs for cover."
Mr Cameron attacked Mr Miliband as "despicable and weak" for not ruling out a post election deal with the SNP.
It came amid a fresh effort to break the TV debate deadlock.
YouTube,
the Guardian and the Daily Telegraph have offered to bring forward the
proposed date of an online debate - which would include the leaders of
the Conservatives, Labour, Lib Dems, UKIP and the Greens - to either 26
or 27 March, in an effort to meet the prime minister's demands any
debate happens before the official campaign begins on 30 March.
Downing Street have said they will "look at" the proposals.
'Wriggle off'
The issue
dominated Prime Minister's Questions - the last but two before polling
day - with the Labour and Conservative leaders in full electioneering
mode, battling deafening noise from MPs.
Mr Miliband said the PM's
handling of the election debate issue "goes to his character," telling
him: "The public will see through your feeble excuses.
"Instead
of these ridiculous tactics, why don't you show a bit more backbone and
turn up for the head-to-head debate with me? Any time, anywhere, any
place."
Mr Cameron claimed Mr Miliband was "despicable" for trying to "crawl
into Downing Street" in alliance "with with people who want to break up
our country".
He challenged the Labour leader to reject a
post-election deal with the SNP, adding that if "he had an ounce of
courage he would rule it out".
Mr Miliband hit back, saying Mr
Cameron would not be would not be able to "wriggle off" the debates and
said "there is only one person preparing for defeat and it is this prime
minister".
"We know you lost to the deputy prime minister last
time, why don't you just cut out the feeble excuses and admit the truth:
you are worried you might lose again?"
'Call the tune'
Mr
Cameron replied: "You want to talk about the future of a television
programme, I want to talk about the future of the country. Four
questions, three weeks to go, you can't talk about jobs because we are
growing jobs. You can't talk unemployment, because unemployment is
plummeting. You can't talk about inflation because it is at a record
low.
"The truth is you are weak and despicable and want to crawl to power in Alex Salmond's pocket."
He said the head-to-head debate should be between the two people who "actually call the tune - that is me and Alex Salmond".
Mr Miliband has repeatedly rejected calls, including from some of his own MPs, to rule out a post-election deal with the SNP.
A
source close to the Labour leader said: "Our position is unchanged. The
only way to get a Labour government is to vote Labour and we will leave
it to others to talk about post election scenarios.
The SNP's leader at Westminster, Angus Robertson, predicted Labour would have to do a deal with the SNP.
"There is an offer on the table," he said.
"If the numbers are such that the Labour party cannot command a majority they will have to work with the SNP."
Although neither leader referred to the digital debates option in the
Commons, Conservative Party chairman Grant Shapps told the BBC's Daily
Politics that seemed a "plausible" way forward.
'Courage'
UKIP
Leader Nigel Farage said: "Scrutiny is an important part of democracy,
and for this reason I am delighted to accept the
Telegraph/Guardian/YouTube invitation to this debate - so that I can
make the case to the British electorate on why they should vote UKIP.
"I
hope that the prime minister will muster up the courage to stand by his
own words, and show up to try and defend his record in government."
Lib
Dem general election co-ordinator Lord Ashdown said the party remained
committed to election debates and would consider the digital debate
proposal.
But he said the prime minister should not be able to let it excuse him from taking part in the equivalent TV debates.
Labour has yet to respond to the digital debate offer.
The proposal is for a five-way debate, which would include UKIP and the Greens.
A Green Party spokesman said the party was "looking forward to receiving
the invitation from the Guardian/YouTube and Telegraph" and would
"relish" the chance to take part.
Planned debate schedule 2 April:
Seven-way debate featuring David Cameron, Ed Miliband, Nick Clegg,
Nigel Farage, Nicola Sturgeon, Natalie Bennett and Leanne Wood (ITV
broadcast) 16 April: Seven-way debate featuring
David Cameron, Ed Miliband, Nick Clegg, Nigel Farage, Nicola Sturgeon,
Natalie Bennett and Leanne Wood (BBC broadcast) 30 April: Head-to-head debate featuring David Cameron and Ed Miliband (Channel 4 and Sky News broadcast) The
BBC, Sky, ITV and Channel 4 plan to hold three live televised debates
in April - two featuring the leaders of Conservatives, Labour, the
Liberal Democrats, the SNP, Plaid Cymru, UKIP and the Green Party, then
one with only Mr Cameron and Labour leader Ed Miliband.
But they
face a threat from the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP), which is angry
at being excluded and is calling for an independent body to be put in
charge of television election debates in a Commons debate on Wednesday.
And last week Mr Cameron said his "final offer" was to take part in a
single debate of seven party leaders before 30 March - an offer which
was rebuffed by the broadcasters who said they would go ahead with their
three planned debates with or without him.
That stance came under
fire on Wednesday morning from former BBC, ITV and Channel 4 boss Lord
Grade, who suggested broadcasters were breaching impartiality rules and
"playing politics".
The Conservative peer said it was "not
acceptable for unelected journalists" to replace David Cameron with an
"empty chair" if he refused to take part in any televised debates.
In
a joint response to Lord Grade's comments, the broadcasters said they
were "trying to deliver debates because we know our audiences want
them".
"In 2010 they were watched by more than 20 million people
and our research suggests there is an appetite for them in 2015. We have
issued invitations to seven party leaders and we continue to hope they
will all agree to take part," they added.
Ed
Miliband has said the pledge of further devolution to Scotland will be
fulfilled "no ifs, no buts" amid a row over additional powers for
England.
He said he and other leaders made a "clear" pledge of new powers during the referendum and they must "honour" it.
The Labour leader said he was "open" to the idea of a new
role for English MPs but not building a new English Parliament, as
favoured by many Tories.
No 10 has made it clear that it will not renege on its Scottish commitments.
But Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond has said voters were
"tricked" by the pledge to publish, in draft form, new powers for the
Scottish Parliament on tax and welfare before the 2015 general election.
He claims the timetable for delivering more powers in the
event of a No vote - promised by the leaders of the three main
Westminster parties in a joint declaration - is slipping because Mr
Cameron can not guarantee his backbenchers, who want more power for
English MPs, will vote for it.
In other developments:
The prime minister is reported to have invited senior Tories to Chequers on Monday to discuss the devolution plans
Justice Secretary Chris Grayling said English voters would be "furious" if they did not get similar powers to those being touted for Scotland
Ed Miliband rules out Gordon Brown returning to frontline
politics after his key role in the referendum campaign but holds out the
prospect of Alistair Darling doing so
The SNP says it has signed up 8,000 new members since the
referendum vote, while Mr Salmond reveals plans to write a book about
the campaign entitled '100 days'
Labour politicians in Wales are urging party leaders to back a fair deal over funding and powers in any discussions on further devolution within the UK
More than 1,000 people attend a special Church service in Edinburgh to celebrate Scotland's "shared values" and "common purpose"
Half the Scottish cabinet publicly back Alex Salmond's deputy, Nicola Sturgeon, to replace him as SNP leader
'Trap'
The prime minister announced on Friday that he wanted
tax-raising powers for Holyrood to be introduced at the same time as
changes to the House of Commons, ending the anomaly which allows
Scottish MPs to vote on English-only legislation, such as health and
education.
Analysis by political correspondent Ross Hawkins
Will Scotland only get more powers in Holyrood if Scottish MPs get fewer votes in Westminster?
It could sound that way. David Cameron said the two matters should be decided "in tandem".
His chief whip Michael Gove said it would be "impossible to
move forward" without being certain of change in Scotland and England.
Yet on the idea of swiftly drawing up plans that could stop
Scottish MPs voting on England-only laws, Ed Miliband disagrees. It
feels a lot like politics as usual.
The pre-referendum arrangement between the Westminster
parties was designed to look very simple. Since the vote, things have
grown complicated.
And yet voices in all three parties are clear - they will
make good their vow to Scotland. No ifs. No buts. The Scottish people
will hold them to it.
Some in the Labour Party fear the surprise announcement is a
"trap" that could undermine a future Labour government, which would rely
on its Scottish MPs to give it a majority on key votes.
Mr Miliband rejected this argument in an interview on the
BBC's Andrew Marr programme, saying most Labour governments had also had
a majority in England.
He refused to be drawn on whether he supports the principle
of England-only votes at Westminster, only saying that he was not
against "greater scrutiny" by English MPs.
Mr Miliband repeated his call for a national debate on the
constitution, saying major changes of the kind being proposed by Mr
Cameron could not be drawn up "on the back of a fag packet". 'Together, not apart'
"Let's not drive our country apart because David Cameron
thinks it is an opportunity for him to do it. Let's keep our country
together and it is very important we do it (change) in the right way."
He suggested the pledge for more powers for Scotland could be
dealt with separately, telling Andrew Marr that the referendum campaign
commitment would be kept.
Alex Salmond "surprised by the speed" at which Westminster party leaders are "reneging" on their promises
"People right across the UK will say David Cameron made a
promise. He did not make a conditional promise. He made a clear promise
and he is going to be kept to that.
"I know David Cameron will want to honour that promise....For
my part, I am going to keep the promise I made…We are going to deliver
on the pledge, no ifs not buts."
The prime minister, he added, had not raised the English
issue with him before they signed their joint "vow" with Lib Dem leader
Nick Clegg ahead of Thursday's referendum.
The BBC's assistant political editor Norman Smith said Labour
was looking at "a grand committee" of English MPs to consider English
laws. 'Non-negotiable'
The head of the Better Together campaign, Alistair Darling,
said the pledge of extra powers for the Scottish Parliament is
"non-negotiable".
"It was promised, it has to be delivered," he told the Andrew
Marr show. "Anyone who welches on that will pay a very high price for
years to come."
"The three leaders gave an absolute commitment. I am confident they will deliver it."
Alistair Darling, Better Together: "Agreement by the three parties... is non-negotiable"
And deputy prime minister Nick Clegg said there were "no ifs,
not buts" about the Scottish devolution pledge and it "cannot be made
contingent on other constitutional reforms".
The Lib Dem leader, writing in the Sunday Times, suggested
the Conservatives were motivated by fears about the rise of UKIP and
that "extreme solutions" to the role of English and Scottish MPs at
Parliament "could jeopardise the union they purport to defend".
Tory chairman Grant Shapps said there would be no "reneging"
on the parties' Scottish commitments but a new English settlement had to
be reached "at the same time".
"We fought for a no vote (in Scotland) even though we don't
benefit," he told Dermot Murnaghan on Sky News "We put politics aside.
Miliband needs to put politics aside."
And Mr Grayling said Holyrood should not receive more powers
while Scottish MPs can still "shape the destiny" of the NHS and schools
in England and force "socialist policies".
"That would be a travesty of democracy, and would be regarded with fury by the English," he told the Sunday Telegraph.