The man accused of bombing the
Boston Marathon in 2013 has been found guilty of all 30 charges that he
faced, many of which carry the death penalty.
The jury in Massachusetts will now decide what sentence 21-year-old Dzhokhar Tsarnaev will receive.
Three people were killed and more than 260 injured when the bombs exploded at the finish line in April 2013.
His lawyers maintained he played a role in the attacks but said his older brother was the driving force.
A police officer was killed in the days following the attack as Tsarnaev and his brother, who also died, attempted to flee.
The decision was reached on Wednesday, after the jury deliberated for just over 12 hours spread over two days.
Tsarnaev kept his hands folded in front of him and looked down as the guilty verdicts were read.
Nearby, the mother of one victim, eight-year-old Martin Richard,
wiped tears from her face after the verdict was read. Richard's father
embraced one of the prosecutors.
The victims
restaurant manager Krystle Campbell, 29, had gone to watch a friend complete the race
Chinese graduate student Lu Lingzi was studying statistics at Boston University
eight-year-old Martin Richard was standing with his family, cheering the runners
Victims' profiles in full The
governor of Massachusetts welcomed the verdict, and Boston Mayor Martin
Walsh said: "I hope today's verdict provides a small amount of
closure".
The family of Officer Sean Collier, who was killed days
after the attack, said: "While today's verdict can never bring Sean
back, we are thankful that Dzhokhar Tsarnaev will be held accountable
for the evil that he brought to so many families."
The conviction
was widely expected because Tsarnaev's chief lawyer, Judy Clarke, made
the surprise admission during opening statements that he took part in
the bombing.
That admission was part of a defence strategy to
paint Tsarnaev's elder brother, Tamerlan, as the mastermind of the
attack who influenced Tsarnaev into participating.
Prosecutors portrayed them as equal partners in a plan to "punish America" for wars in Muslim countries.
Among
the most damning evidence was a video that showed Tsarnaev placing a
backpack bomb near to Martin Richard, and a statement scrawled inside
the boat where he was found hiding days after the attack.
"Stop
killing our innocent people and we will stop," he wrote, as he lay
wounded and bleeding inside the dry-docked boat in suburban garden.
The
jury was also shown a surveillance video of Tsarnaev casually
purchasing milk at a nearby supermarket less than 30 minutes after the
bombs wreaked carnage at the finish line.
At the scene: Tara McKelvey, BBC News
A court official warned against emotional outbursts as the verdict was read.
"There is to be no reactions," he told people in the room. "Maintain complete silence."
People
on the government's side, near the FBI agents and the Watertown,
Massachusetts, police chief, had cried as they watched videos of the
bombings. Today they were quiet as the verdicts were read: "guilty,
guilty, guilty".
Earlier Tsarnaev had given his lawyer, Judy Clarke, a half-fist-bump.
She didn't return it. This afternoon he was more subdued. He stood and
paid close attention as the verdicts were read, occasionally rocking
from side to side. He put his hands in his pockets then took them out
quickly. He has long lashes, and he blinked a lot. When he was led out
of the room, he walked quickly, as before, but his step was less
springy. The
jury will now have to decide whether Tsarnaev faces the death penalty
as the trial moves into its second phase, which could begin as early as
Monday.
Tsarnaev is an ethnic Chechen. His family moved to the US about a decade before the bombings.
A prosecutor has told the jury that
Dzhokar Tsarnaev "wanted to punish America" when he and his brother
planted bombs at the Boston Marathon.
"He wanted to terrorise this country," his lawyer said as closing arguments began at the trial in Boston.
If found guilty, the 21-year-old, who is charged with 30 counts, will face life imprisonment or execution.
His lawyers admit he carried out the attacks but say he was under the influence of his radicalised brother.
Three
people, including an eight-year-old boy, died after two pressure cooker
bombs packed with nails, ball bearings and other shrapnel detonated in
April 2013. More than 260 people were injured, with many losing limbs. A
police officer was shot dead during the massive manhunt.
Assistant US Attorney Aloke Chakravarty said that Mr Tsarnaev targeted
the marathon in 2013, because it was a day when the world's attention
would be focused on Boston.
"The defendant thought that his values were more important than the
people around him. He wanted to awake the mujahedeen, the holy
warriors," he said.
"He wanted to terrorise this country. He wanted to punish America for what it was doing to his people."
Mr Tsarnaev shook his head slightly when Mr Chakravarty referred to him as a terrorist.
As
expected, defence attorneys underscored their argument that Mr
Tsarnaev was acting under the influence of his elder brother, Tamerlan,
who orchestrated the plot.
"Tamerlan built the bombs, Tamerlan
murdered officer Collier, Tamerlan lead and Dzhokhar followed," lead
defence lawyer Judy Clarke said.
The court was filled with people who have been affected by the
bombings and the subsequent manhunt, with several people displaying
visible signs of their victimhood - prosthetics, wheelchairs, and
hearing aids have all been seen in the courtroom.
Defence lawyers
have maintained that his 26-year-old brother, Tamerlan, who died during a
massive manhunt, had orchestrated the attacks and by doing so they hope
to spare their client the death penalty.
If convicted, a second phase will determine the punishment, and the jury will have to decide whether he will be put to death.
The attacks were the deadliest terror attack on US soil since 9/11.
The trial of the man accused of
bombing the Boston Marathon two years ago has begun, with his defence
lawyer telling the jury he committed the crime.
"It was him," the
lawyer said as she prepared to defend Dzhokhar Tsarnaev's actions by
saying he had been influenced by his older brother.
Mr Tsarnaev, 21, could face the death penalty and is charged with more than 30 counts relating to the bombings.
It was the deadliest terror attack on US soil since 9/11.
Speaking
before the defence, a federal prosecutor said in opening statements on
Wednesday that Tsarnaev had "murder in his heart" when he placed the
bomb.
In 2013, Mr Tsarnaev pleaded not guilty to all charges related to the attack.
The left side of the court was filled with about two dozen of the attack's victims as the trial began.
Three
people, including an eight-year-old boy, were killed after two pressure
cooker bombs packed with nails, ball bearings and other shrapnel
detonated in April 2013.
More than 260 people were injured, with many losing limbs.
Opening statements
The
prosecutor delivered his statements first. Mr Tsarnaev's lead defence
attorney followed, and immediately shocked the court by candidly telling
the jury that he was responsible for the attack.
The 21-year-old
suspect slouched in his chair and stared straight ahead as the
prosecutor, William Weinreb, began his opening statement.
Detailing
the scene near the finish line just under two years ago, the prosecutor
said: "The air was filled with the smell of burning sulphur and
people's screams."
Mr Weinreb described the backpack bomb that Mr
Tsarnaev allegedly planted at the finish as "the type of bombs favoured
by terrorists because it's designed to tear people apart and create a
bloody spectacle."
Among those in attendance were Denise and Bill Richard, whose 8-year-old son, Martin, died in the bombings.
As
they looked on, the prosecutor told the jury that Ms Richard watched
helplessly as "the bomb tore large chunks of flesh out of Martin
Richard".
The boy had been standing on a metal barrier with other children so
that he could better see the runners crossing the finish line.
Heather Abbott, who lost a leg in the attack, sat near the Richard family.
"While
victims of the bombing lay in the hospital and learned that they would
have to have their limbs chopped off to save their lives, the defendant
pretended that nothing had happened," Mr Weinreb said, noting that Mr
Tsarnaev returned to socialise with his friends at the University of
Massachusetts-Dartmouth following the attack.
Judy Clarke, a famed attorney who has represented a number of
high-profile suspects in the past, began her opening remarks by saying:
"It was him."
She said that her team would not attempt to
"sidestep" Mr Tsarnaev's guilt in carrying out the "senseless, horribly
misguided acts carried out by two brothers".
Instead, she will
argue that his elder brother, Tamerlan, was the mastermind of the plot
and coerced the younger sibling into being a submissive participant.
Mr Tsarnaev is also accused of killing a police officer in the days after the bombing.
A huge police manhunt followed the attacks, culminating in Mr Tsarnaev's arrest and the death of his elder brother.
LOWELL, Mass. — Boston's police department and mayor's office will conduct twin reviews of the response to last month's bombing of the Boston Marathon, police commissioner Ed Davis said Saturday.
Davis said the aim of the reviews is to learn from the experience and prepare for the future.
"We are very anxious to get those reviews under way and learn lessons from anything that might pop up as an issue of concern," Davis said. "I expect that this whole year will be a time of review and reflection on what happened."
Davis addressed reporters after delivering the commencement address at the University of Massachusetts Lowell. The event occurred a little more than a month after the April 15 bombings that killed three people and wounded more than 260. The attacks made Davis a national figure.
He said one review, of all of the city's response services, will be conducted under the leadership of Mayor Thomas Menino and his office of Emergency Management. The second investigation will look at best practices and will be funded by the U.S. Department of Justice Office of Community Oriented Policing Services.
"I fervently hope that each of these reviews help us learn more about our emergency services and will allow us to better prepare for other large-scale events in our future," Davis told hundreds of graduates, their families and faculty.
He couldn't immediately say when the investigations will start, only that he expects them to take "a few months." He did not know how much they are likely to cost.
Davis indicated that the bombings have changed the perspective of the city police department. He noted that ahead of the July 4 celebration in Boston, police officers will travel to New York City for additional training on securing large-scale public events.
Davis says he is continuously asked what he learned from the bombings and following days.
"I learned to think the unthinkable," he said. "I learned that the most horrific of circumstances can produce the most inspirational and heroic of actions, not just by one single person, but by hundreds of them."
Davies said Boston police Officer Tom Barrett used his hand to put out the flames of a person set on fire by one of the blasts. He also named Jeff Bauman, the bombing victim who provided a description of one of the bombers after having his legs blown off, and the man who helped Bauman into a wheelchair.
The 57-year-old Davis received an honorary Doctor of Humane Letters. Nearly 3,200 students received degrees.
Davis is a Lowell native who began his police career as a patrolman in the city. He rose through the ranks and ran its police department for 12 years until being named commissioner in Boston in 2006.
He told the graduates that lessons he learned over the years were valuable in the aftermath of the April 15 bombings.
"If you take away nothing else from my remarks today, you must realize that every single day for the rest of your life is going to provide a learning opportunity for you," Davis said. "Many of you believe that when you leave this arena today with your UMass Lowell diploma in hand your days of learning are over ... you're only getting started."
BOSTON -- The family of slain Boston Marathon bombing suspect Tamerlan Tsarnaev was making arrangements Friday for his funeral as investigators searched the woods near the college attended by his younger brother and alleged accomplice.
A funeral parlor in Worcester that is familiar with Muslim services said it will handle arrangements for Tsarnaev, whose body was released by the state medical examiner Thursday night.
The body was taken initially to a North Attleborough funeral home, where it was greeted by about 20 protesters. Peter Stefan, owner of Graham Putnam and Mahoney Funeral Parlors in Worcester, said everybody deserves a dignified burial service no matter the circumstances of their death and he is prepared for protests.
Tsarnaev, 26, died three days after the bombing in a furious getaway attempt in which authorities say he and his brother, ethnic Chechens from Russia who came to the United States about a decade ago, killed an MIT campus police officer and tossed home-made bombs and grenades at police. The younger brother, 19-year-old Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, ran over his brother's body as he drove away from the scene to escape, authorities have said.
The medical examiner had yet to release the cause of death, pending the filing of a death certificate.
Relatives had said they would claim the body, but Stefan said Friday funeral arrangements had yet to be worked out and he could not say whether he has possession of the body.
Meanwhile, two U.S. officials said Dzhokhar Tsarnaev told interrogators that he and his brother initially considered setting off their bombs on July Fourth.
Boston police said they planned to review security procedures for the Independence Day Boston Pops concert and fireworks display, which draws a crowd of more than 500,000 annually and is broadcast to a national TV audience. Authorities plan to look at security procedures for large events held in other cities, notably the massive New Year's Eve celebration held each year in New York City's Times Square, said David Procopio, a spokesman for the Massachusetts State Police.
Gov. Deval Patrick said everything possible will be done to assure a safe event.
"I think the most important thing is that we got them, and there's investigation continuing about where the other leads may lead," he said. "I can tell you, having been thoroughly briefed, that the law enforcement at every level is pursuing everything."
As part of the bombing investigation, federal, state and local authorities were searching the woods near the UMass-Dartmouth campus, where Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was a student. Christina DiIorio-Sterling, a spokeswoman for U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz, could not say what investigators were looking for but said residents should know there is no threat to public safety.
Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, who was found hiding in a tarp-covered boat in a suburban Boston backyard, faces a charge of using a weapon of mass destruction to kill. Three of his college classmates were arrested Wednesday and accused of helping after the bombing to remove a laptop and backpack from his dormitory room before the FBI searched it.
The April 15 bombing, using pressure cookers packed with explosives, nails, ball bearings and metal shards, killed three people and injured more than 260 others near the marathon's finish line.
The brothers considered setting off their bombs on July Fourth, but they decided to carry out the attack sooner when they finished assembling the bombs, the surviving suspect told interrogators after he was arrested, according to two U.S. officials briefed on the investigation. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity, because they were not authorized to discuss the ongoing investigation.
Investigators believe some of the explosives used in the attack were assembled in Tamerlan Tsarnaev's home, though there may have been some assembly elsewhere, one of the officials said. At this point, it does not appear that the brothers ever had big, definitive plans, the official said.
The brothers' mother insists the allegations against them are lies.
Meanwhile, the Homeland Security Department ordered border agents to immediately being verifying that every international student who arrives in the U.S. has a valid student visa, according to an internal memorandum obtained Friday by The Associated Press. The new procedure is the government's first security change directly related to the Boston bombings.
The order from a senior official at U.S. Customs and Border Protection, David J. Murphy, was circulated Thursday and came one day after the Obama administration acknowledged that one of the students accused of hiding evidence, Azamat Tazhayakov of Kazakhstan, was allowed to return to the U.S. in January without a valid student visa.
A benefit concert featuring Aerosmith, James Taylor and Jimmy Buffett is scheduled for May 30 at the TD Garden in Boston. The proceeds will go to The One Fund, which has taken in more than $28 million so far for those injured and the families of those who were killed.
Kenneth Feinberg, the fund's administrator, said Friday he plans to hold meetings with victims next week and begin cutting checks by the end of June.
BOSTON -- The defense team representing the Boston Marathon bombing suspect got a major boost Monday with the addition of Judy Clarke, a San Diego lawyer who has managed to get life sentences instead of the death penalty for several high-profile clients, including the Unabomber and the gunman in the rampage that injured former Arizona Rep. Gabrielle Giffords.
The appointment of Clarke, based in San Diego, Calif., was approved Monday by U.S. Magistrate Judge Marianne Bowler.
Bowler denied, at least for now, a request from Miriam Conrad, the public defender of 19-year-old suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, to appoint a second death penalty lawyer - David Bruck, a professor at Washington and Lee University School of Law.
Tsarnaev has been charged with using a weapon of mass destruction during the April 15 marathon. Three people were killed and more than 260 injured when two bombs exploded near the finish line.
The suspect's lawyers could renew their motion to appoint another death penalty expert if he is indicted, the judge said.
Clarke's clients have included the Unabomber, Ted Kaczynski; Susan Smith, who drowned her two children; Atlanta Olympics bomber Eric Rudolph; and most recently Tucson, Ariz., shooter Jared Loughner. All received life sentences instead of the death penalty.
Clarke has rarely spoken publicly about her work and did not return a call seeking comment Monday. However, at a speech Friday at a legal conference in Los Angeles, she talked about how she had been "sucked into the black hole, the vortex" of death penalty cases 18 years ago when she represented Smith.
"I got a dose of understanding human behavior, and I learned what the death penalty does to us," she said. "I don't think it's a secret that I oppose the death penalty."
Bruck has directed Washington and Lee's death penalty defense clinic, the Virginia Capital Case Clearinghouse, since 2004.
In other developments in the Boston case:
- FBI agents visited the Rhode Island home of the in-laws of the suspect's brother, Tamerlan Tsarnaev, and carried away several bags. The brother was killed in a gun battle with police.
Katherine Russell, Tsarnaev's widow, has been staying at the North Kingstown home and did not speak to reporters as she left her attorneys' office in Providence later in the day. Attorney Amato DeLuca says she's doing everything she can to assist with the investigation.
- President Barack Obama and Russian President Vladimir Putin discussed terrorism coordination Monday in the wake of the Boston Marathon bombings. Obama expressed his "appreciation" for Russia's close cooperation after the attack.
The suspected bombers are Russian natives who immigrated to the Boston area. Russian authorities told U.S. officials before the bombings they had concerns about the family, but only revealed details of wiretapped conversations since the attack.
BOSTON -- The angry and grieving mother of the Boston Marathon bombing suspects insists that her sons are innocent and that she's no terrorist.
But Zubeidat Tsarnaeva is drawing increased attention after federal officials say Russian authorities intercepted her phone calls, including one in which she vaguely discussed jihad with her elder son. In another, she was recorded talking to someone in southern Russia who is under FBI investigation in an unrelated case, U.S. officials said.
In photos of her as a younger woman, Tsarnaeva wears a low-cut blouse and has her hair teased like a 1980s rock star. After she arrived in the U.S. from Russia in 2002, she went to beauty school and did facials at a suburban day spa.
But in recent years, people noticed a change. She began wearing a hijab and cited conspiracy theories about 9/11 being a plot against Muslims.
Tsarnaeva insists there is no mystery and that she's just someone who found a deeper spirituality. She fiercely defends her sons - Tamerlan, who was killed in a gunfight with police, and Dzhokhar, who was wounded and captured.
"It's all lies and hypocrisy," she told The Associated Press in Dagestan. "I'm sick and tired of all this nonsense that they make up about me and my children. People know me as a regular person, and I've never been mixed up in any criminal intentions, especially any linked to terrorism."
At a news conference in Dagestan with her ex-husband Anzor Tsarnaev last week, Tsarnaeva appeared overwhelmed with grief one moment, defiant the next. "They already are talking about that we are terrorists, I am terrorist," she said. "They already want me, him and all of us to look (like) terrorists."
Amid the scrutiny, Tsarnaeva and Anzor say they have put off the idea of any trip to the U.S. to reclaim their elder son's body or try to visit Dzhokhar in jail. Tsarnaev told the AP on Sunday he was too ill to travel to the U.S. Tsarnaeva faces a 2012 shoplifting charge in a Boston suburb, though it was unclear whether that was a deterrent.
Tsarnaeva arrived in the U.S. in 2002, settling in a working-class section of Cambridge, Mass. With four children, Anzor and Zubeidat qualified for food stamps and were on and off public assistance benefits for years. The large family squeezed itself into a third-floor apartment.
Zubeidat took classes at the Catherine Hinds Institute of Esthetics, before becoming a state-licensed aesthetician. Anzor, who had studied law, fixed cars.
By some accounts, the family was tolerant.
Bethany Smith, a New Yorker who befriended Zubeidat's two daughters, said in an interview with Newsday that when she stayed with the family for a month in 2008 while she looked at colleges, she was welcomed even though she was Christian and had tattoos.
"I had nothing but love over there. They accepted me for who I was," Smith told the newspaper. "Their mother, Zubeidat, she considered me to be a part of the family. She called me her third daughter."
Zubeidat said she and Tamerlan began to turn more deeply into their Muslim faith about five years ago after being influenced by a family friend, named "Misha." The man, whose full name she didn't reveal, impressed her with a religious devotion that was far greater than her own, even though he was an ethnic Armenian who converted to Islam.
"I wasn't praying until he prayed in our house, so I just got really ashamed that I am not praying, being a Muslim, being born Muslim. I am not praying. Misha, who converted, was praying," she said.
By then, she had left her job at the day spa and was giving facials in her apartment. One client, Alyssa Kilzer, noticed the change when Tsarnaeva put on a head scarf before leaving the apartment.
"She had never worn a hijab while working at the spa previously, or inside the house, and I was really surprised," Kilzer wrote in a post on her blog. "She started to refuse to see boys that had gone through puberty, as she had consulted a religious figure and he had told her it was sacrilegious. She was often fasting."
Kilzer wrote that Tsarnaeva was a loving and supportive mother, and she felt sympathy for her plight after the April 15 bombings. But she stopped visiting the family's home for spa treatments in late 2011 or early 2012 when, during one session, she "started quoting a conspiracy theory, telling me that she thought 9/11 was purposefully created by the American government to make America hate Muslims."
"It's real," Tsarnaeva said, according to Kilzer. "My son knows all about it. You can read on the Internet."
In the spring of 2010, Zubeidat's eldest son got married in a ceremony at a Boston mosque that no one in the family had previously attended. Tamerlan and his wife, Katherine Russell, a Rhode Island native and convert from Christianity, now have a child who is about 3 years old.
Zubeidat married into a Chechen family but was an outsider. She is an Avar, from one of the dozens of ethnic groups in Dagestan. Her native village is now a hotbed of an ultraconservative strain of Islam known as Salafism or Wahabbism.
It is unclear whether religious differences fueled tension in their family. Anzor and Zubeidat divorced in 2011.
About the same time, there was a brief FBI investigation into Tamerlan Tsarnaev, prompted by a tip from Russia's security service.
The vague warning from the Russians was that Tamerlan, an amateur boxer in the U.S., was a follower of radical Islam who had changed drastically since 2010. That led the FBI to interview Tamerlan at the family's home in Cambridge. Officials ultimately placed his name, and his mother's name, on various watch lists, but the inquiry was closed in late spring of 2011.
After the bombings, Russian authorities told U.S. investigators they had secretly recorded a phone conversation in which Zubeidat had vaguely discussed jihad with Tamerlan. The Russians also recorded Zubeidat talking to someone in southern Russia who is under FBI investigation in an unrelated case, according to U.S. officials who spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the investigation with reporters.
The conversations are significant because, had they been revealed earlier, they might have been enough evidence for the FBI to initiate a more thorough investigation of the Tsarnaev family.
Rep. Peter King, a member of the House Homeland Security Committee, told NBC's "Today" show Monday he believes the FBI investigation of the two young men would have gone much further if the Russian government had informed Washington of "the mother's radicalization, the son's radicalization. .. It definitely would have caused the investigation to go further."
Anzor's brother, Ruslan Tsarni, told the AP from his home in Maryland that he believed his former sister-in-law had a "big-time influence" on her older son's growing embrace of his Muslim faith and decision to quit boxing and school.
While Tamerlan was living in Russia for six months in 2012, Zubeidat, who had remained in the U.S., was arrested at a shopping mall in the suburb of Natick, Mass., and accused of trying to shoplift $1,624 worth of women's clothing from a department store.
She failed to appear in court to answer the charges that fall, and instead left the country.