“AS A democracy the United States ought presumably to be able to
dispense with dynastic families,” wrote Arthur Schlesinger junior, one
of America’s best-known historians, in 1947. Yet almost 70 years on,
next year’s presidential election could well become a family affair. A
Clinton or a Bush has been on the ticket in seven of the past nine
races. Hillary v Jeb may offend against equal opportunity, but not the
laws of statistics.
How, people wonder, can this happen in a country that went to war to
rid itself of a king’s hereditary authority? That is the wrong question.
Around the world, in politics and business, power is still concentrated
in the family. Power families and dynasties are here to stay. The
question is how to ensure that they are a force for good.
Double helix, double standards
In politics the Clintons and the Bushes hardly count as exceptions.
The leaders of Japan, South Korea, the Philippines and Bangladesh are
all related to former political chiefs. The “Stans” of Central Asia are
family fiefs. The Gandhis are struggling in India, as are the Bhuttos in
Pakistan, but the Kenyattas are kings in Kenya, a Fujimori is once
again leading the polls in Peru and a Trudeau has a fighting chance in
Canada. Meanwhile the lengthy catalogue of China’s “princelings”, the
children of Communist Party grandees, starts right at the top with the
president, Xi Jinping.
In Europe family power is one reason why politics seems like a closed
shop. Fifty-seven of the 650 members of the recently dissolved British
Parliament are related to current or former MPs. François Hollande,
France’s president, has four children with Ségolène Royal, who ran for
the presidency in 2007. Three generations of Le Pens are squabbling over
their insurgent party, the Front National (see
article).
Belgium’s prime minister is the son of a former foreign minister and
European commissioner. The names Papandreou and Karamanlis still count
for something in Greece.
In business, too, family companies continue to thrive, as our special
report in this issue explains. More than 90% of the world’s businesses
are family-managed or -controlled, including some of the biggest, such
as News Corp and Volkswagen, a carmaker in the throes of a boardroom
battle between its two main family owners. The Boston Consulting Group
calculates that families own or control 33% of American companies and
40% of French and German ones with revenues of more than $1 billion a
year. In the emerging world the preponderance of family control is
greater still.
The importance of power families would have surprised the founders of
modern economic and political theory. Political dynasties were supposed
to fade as ordinary people got the vote. Family businesses were
supposed to lose ground as public companies raised money from millions
of small investors.
This never happened—partly because many advantages of kinship proved
surprisingly enduring. Political dynasties have a powerful mixture of
brand names and personal connections. Family companies can be more
flexible and far-seeing than public companies. Family owners typically
want their firms to last for generations, and they can make long-term
investments without worrying about shareholders hunting for immediate
profits.
Power families have also prospered from big, and welcome, social and
economic shifts. Their prominence reflects the increasing prosperity of
Asia, where families traditionally play a large role. The emancipation
of women is doubling the talent pool. In an earlier age political
chauvinism would have excluded Park Geun-hye, Keiko Fujimori—and Mrs
Clinton. Likewise women have successfully taken the reins at Spain’s
Santander bank, Australia’s Hancock Prospecting, and even Saudi Arabia’s
Olayan Financing Company.
However, family power poses problems. Liberals, such as this
newspaper, believe in the importance of protecting private property and
allowing entrepreneurs to enjoy the fruits of their talents. But at the
same time they believe that people should be judged on their individual
merits rather than their family connections or their brand name. The
New York Times
reckons that the son of a governor is 6,000 times more likely than the
average American male baby-boomer to become a governor himself, and the
son of a senator is 8,500 times more likely to become a senator. The
concentration of power and wealth in a small elite raises questions
about legitimacy.
Family power also has its dark side—especially where business and
politics are entwined in an exclusive nexus of money and influence (see
article).
The Clintons are a worrying example: all sorts of people, including
foreign governments, have given millions to the Clinton family
foundation, perhaps in part because they think it will give them
influence over a future president. Lazy incumbents have an incentive to
use political connections to protect themselves from competition. This
can lead to corruption. A study found that in 2003 firms representing
almost 8% of the world’s market capitalisation were run by relatives of
their countries’ political leaders. Even without political connections,
business families can exercise an unhealthy influence over the wider
economy. Pyramid ownership structures enable a small chunk of capital to
exert a large degree of control. Another study found that the richest
ten families controlled 34% of market capitalisation in Portugal and 29%
in both France and Switzerland.
Family values, public goods
The secret to healthy family power is competition. In an open system
of free markets, governed by the rule of law and held to account by a
free press, nepotism matters less. America’s vastly expensive elections
favour political machines: another reason to re-examine campaign
finance. Pyramid structures lock up capital markets. America limited
them in the 1930s. Britain followed suit in the late 1960s and Israel is
doing the same. So should other countries. Inheritance taxes in places
such as Britain favour the family company: it should survive on its
merits. Family power, like any other sort, needs watching over. If it
cannot be contested, it should not be welcome.