TO SEE George W. Bush on stage in Charleston on February 15th,
exuding that old aw-shucks charm, as he told corny jokes and wisecracked
about his supposed lack of intelligence, was to recall the presidential
standup act that disappeared so suddenly, back to Texas, almost as if
his eight years in the White House had never happened. A few in the
South Carolinian crowd marvelled that they ever had; even among
Republicans Mr Bush is divisive. Around a quarter rate his presidency
highly; a third say it was “poor”.
That is one reason why this was his first public appearance,
alongside his wife Laura and brother Jeb, in Jeb’s presidential
campaign. Another was to mitigate the unpleasant whiff of dynasticism
that clings to it; Jeb’s campaign coffers were filled by friends of the
Bush brothers’ daddy, President George H.W. Bush, as were George W.’s
coffers before him. A third reason was that George W., now happily
retired to paint bad pictures and grow trees on his ranch, has become
even more contentious during the primary contest, as his legacy, of
military fiasco, lavish spending and a failed stab at immigration
reform, has come under attack from Jeb’s rivals. At a Republican debate
in South Carolina on February 13th Donald Trump accused George W. of
wittingly invading Iraq on a false prospectus and failing to “keep
America safe”—the phrase apologists for the discredited president are
most likely to use in his defence.
But if his appearance in Charleston was in that sense inauspicious,
it was justified as an act of desperation. Trounced in Iowa, only
slightly redeemed in New Hampshire, Jeb!—as image consultants have
branded him—needs at least to beat Marco Rubio, his main rival for the
establishment vote, in South Carolina on February 20th if he is to avoid
humiliation and abandonment by his father’s friends. His advisers
believed that George W., whose own presidential ambitions were once
saved by South Carolina and who is liked by its many ex-servicemen,
might be the filip he needs. “Bush country,” they call the state.
There was noisy enthusiasm for the former president in the crowd—of a
thousand or so white-haired pensioners, servicemen with buzz-cuts and
proper-looking professionals, some with children. Most said they had
come, on Presidents’ Day, mainly to see George W., not his brother. “He
was my president when I enlisted,” said Joseph Beaudeg, a 30-year-old
marine, who had brought his six-year-old daughter to “see a
president”.“This is why we’re here,” said Rutledge Young, a lawyer,
pointing to his discreet “W” lapel badge. Only a handful volunteered
much enthusiasm for Jeb. Miranda Dobbins, a college administrator and
Ted Cruz fan, was one of several who said they had not given him much
thought.
What accounts for the brothers’ contrasting political fortunes? It is
not all Mr Trump’s doing—though his ridiculing of Jeb as a “low-energy”
dolt has been relentless and brilliant. (“I said, Why don’t you use the
last name, you’ll do better—believe me, it’s better than exclamation
points,” Mr Trump chipped in this week.) One explanation is that George
W. is a much better retail politician than the wonkish former governor
of Florida will ever be.
When “W” told an execrable joke about being a tree farmer (“It helps
me practice my stump speech!”), it was almost funny; the crowd loved it.
When Jeb! cracked a better gag—he claimed to have vetoed so much
regulation in Florida that they called him Veto Corleone—no one laughed.
In a rare serious remark—in a speech in which he did not deign to name
any of his brother’s rivals—George W. declared himself proud to be a
member of the reviled establishment. Yet with his blokeish manner,
accident-prone English and earnest religiosity, he never seemed
particularly like one. By contrast stiff, proper Jeb, though in some
ways, including his bilingual household, less conventional than George
W., seems like a man prone to wear chequered golfing slacks to unwind.
That makes him, metaphorically speaking, not well-suited to America’s
distempered electorate.
There was little reason, with the primary vote looming, to suppose
George W.’s return from obscurity would fix that. The Bush brothers’
first instincts were right; if Jeb’s famous relatives may boost him with
some voters, they will turn off others. Moreover, South Carolina is not
really Bush country these days. The mixture of social conservatism and
pro-business posturing that won the state for George W. in 2000 did not
work for Mitt Romney, the Republican nominee in 2012. He lost South
Carolina to the more acerbic Newt Gingrich, whose attacks on Washington
found favour with anti-government Tea Partiers and disaffected
working-class whites.
That both groups had suffered a crashing loss of confidence in
steady-as-she-goes establishment conservativism was chiefly because of
the economic and foreign policy calamities George W. presided over. And
the suspicion and contempt they engendered endures, which is why all the
mainstream Republican candidates—even more compelling ones than
Jeb!—are now struggling. It was rather heart-warming to hear the
nostalgic, faintly defiant cheers for George W. from a crowd of
cautious, quietly prosperous Republicans who do not want a thuggish
property tycoon to rip America up and make it great again. But the
evidence suggests that W. played his main hand in this race years ago,
and it has not turned out well.