The beginning of the end
SOMETIMES a heckler can be a politician’s best friend. Giving
his fullest account of counter-terrorism policy for some years in an
hour-long
speech
to the National Defense University on May 23rd, President Barack Obama
was repeatedly and loudly interrupted by a woman protester demanding the
immediate closure of the Guantánamo Bay prison camp and greater respect
for the rule of law.
The heckling helped Mr Obama, whose speech
had until then felt like an address to a straw man—some imaginary
citizen of tender conscience who needed to be assured that America was
right to target terrorists with lethal drone strikes in Pakistan or
Yemen, and needed reminding that it was not that easy to close
Guantánamo or put terror suspects on trial in mainland American courts.
True,
left-wing supporters of the president are upset with his use of armed
drones, and hate the idea that American guards and doctors are
force-feeding more than 100 detainees on hunger strike in Guantánamo.
But most ordinary Americans tell pollsters that they thoroughly approve
of killing suspected terrorists with remote strikes in the badlands of
Afghanistan, Pakistan or Yemen. The most potent political challenges to
the president’s conduct of the war on terror have to date come from the
Right.
Republicans delight in portraying Mr Obama and his
government as being soft on Islamic extremists, most recently denouncing
his attorney-general, Eric Holder, for allowing the surviving Boston
bombing suspect to be read his civilian legal rights. In the view of
several conservatives in Congress, Dzhokhar Tsarnaev should have been
thrown into the legal limbo of Guantánamo and interrogated, without any
nonsense about lawyers and a right to remain silent.
Mr Obama took
office in 2008 vowing to close Guantánamo's prison camp swiftly,
transferring many detainees back to their home countries and putting
others, including high-profile suspected al-Qaeda leaders, on trial in
federal courts on the mainland, rather than at military tribunals in the
international limbo of an American naval base on Cuba.
The
president signed an order to that effect in 2009 but the effort was
starved of funding by Republicans in Congress, joined by scores of
Democrats, fearful of being seen as soft on security. Congress finally
passed a law banning any transfer of detainees to America, even for
trial.
In his speech today, Mr Obama acknowledged that Guantánamo
remained a knotty problem, as it held detainees “known” to have taken
part in terror attacks but who could not be prosecuted in civilian
courts for lack of admissible evidence. With more solemnity than
substance, the president once again called on Congress to lift
restrictions on detainee transfers from “Gitmo” (as he called the camp,
using a military abbreviation), and pledged to seek a location in
America to hold military commissions. At the same time the president
said he would lift his own moratorium on sending detainees to Yemen.
The
president stopped several times to allow the lone heckler, from the
anti-war movement Code Pink, to berate him over his policies, and
suggested that the situation at Guantánamo Bay was unsustainable and
un-American. “Look at the current situation, where we are force-feeding
detainees who are holding a hunger strike. Is that who we are? Is that
something that our founders foresaw?” he asked.
The meatiest part
of the speech covered instruments of war and remote-controlled force
that are fully in the president’s power, starting with the armed drones
strikes with which Mr Obama has killed dozens of terror suspects. Those
killed include four American citizens, a death toll only fully revealed
on the eve of the president’s speech.
His defence of such strikes
was not really aimed at the American public. It was aimed at the curious
coalition of critics who charge him with killing terrorists who would
more properly be captured alive: a coalition made up of left-wing
Democrats, foreign politicians and right-wing Republicans bent on
finding ways to attack a president who they despise.
The president
defended drone strikes as more precise than conventional attacks from
the air, and less dangerous than operations involving American “boots on
the ground”. The raid by special forces in Pakistan that killed Osama
bin Laden “cannot be the norm”, he said. The risks had been immense,
with a healthy dose of luck helping to prevent civilian casualties or an
extended firefight.
Though strikes by distant drones were legal
and had saved lives, Mr Obama announced that he had signed a new
framework of guidelines, oversight and accountability governing the use
of force against terrorism. Describing the deaths of civilian bystanders
in drone strikes as “heartbreaking tragedies”, the president pledged
that drone strikes would only be used when the capture of terror
suspects was impossible, when terrorists posed a “continuing and
imminent threat to the American people”, when no other government was
capable of effectively addressing that threat and when there was a
“near-certainty” that no civilians would be killed or injured.
In a
reminder that the majority of the American public takes an essentially
parochial view of drones, Mr Obama also found time to address the
paranoid concern raised by such Republican senators as Rand Paul and Ted
Cruz that the government might send armed drones to prowl the skies
over America, to take out Americans suspected of terrorism without a
trial. For the record, Mr Obama said, he did not believe it would be
constitutional for the government to target and kill any American
citizen—whether with a drone or a shotgun—without due process. Nor
should any president deploy armed drones over American soil, he added.
But
he defended the killing of Anwar Awlaki, accusing him of plotting to
blow up airplanes, and saying that when an American goes abroad to wage
war against America and cannot be captured before carrying out a plot,
his citizenship should no more shield him than a sniper shooting on a
crowd should be protected from police marksmen.
The president’s
tone was more pedagogical than bombastic. He sounded like the man that
he has become: a former constitutional law professor of liberal
instincts, turned commander-in-chief of a superpower that aspires to
global respect, but must keep vigil against those who hate it with
murderous intensity.
After more than a decade of intense
war-fighting, he described a world of more diffuse, local threats from
affiliates of al-Qaeda, extremists in loose regional networks or
radicalised individuals, including American citizens or legal residents
already in the country. The scale of the threat resembled the dangers
that faced America before the September 11th 2001 attacks on New York
and Washington, DC, he said.
The real message of the president’s
address is that the global war on terror begun on a sunny day in
September 2001, in the horror of sudden attack, must and will end. He
explicitly acknowledged a legal and political headache that privately
alarms his closest advisers—the threadbare legal authority underpinning
the war on terror, that dates back to a few phrases of war-making
authority passed by Congress just days after September 11th.
That
war-making authority needed to be refined, and ultimately repealed, the
president said, suggesting that the fight against terrorism had to
become less an armed conflict, and more an ongoing effort to dismantle
terrorist groups. He vowed not to sign any law expanding the 2001
mandate further. “This war like all wars must end,” Mr Obama said.
“That’s what history advises. That’s what our democracy demands.”