Biodun Iginla, BBC News

Biodun Iginla, BBC News

Friday, May 3, 2013

Sudan's rebel wars reach placid heartland


Related Topics

Residents walk past a bank damaged during attacks by insurgents who stormed the city, in Um Rawaba May 2, 2013. REUTERS/Mohamed Nureldin Abdallah
The line of army pickup trucks rumbled into the dusty streets of Um Rawaba, a once placid city in the heart of Sudan that days ago became a new front in the war of attrition between government and rebels.
Six days earlier, hundreds of insurgents had stormed in, spraying bullets and killing up to 13 civilians and soldiers, before pulling out as government planes started flying overhead.
A week on, Um Rawaba's traders and shoppers cheered and gave "thumbs-up" signs as the latest government reinforcements arrived and drove past buildings still bearing the scars of the attack.
Even as government minders looked on, some citizens acknowledged they were worried.
"This was the first time we had such an attack ... We want security," trader Omar Kuf told Reuters on Thursday.
Sudan has long been plagued by rebel attacks - but there were at least two main reasons for the Khartoum government to sit up and take particular notice after this assault.
Almost all the past turmoil has sprung up in the country's distant and arid peripheries, not in North Kordofan, the region that includes Um Rawaba and forms part of Sudan's commercial heartland, a hub for its agriculture, livestock and gum arabic industries.
Second, many of the earlier uprisings have been focused affairs - between the government and rebels fighting over grievances in their particular territories, among them Darfur, South Kordofan and Blue Nile.
But this was a coordinated attack by members of those rebel groups, fighting together under the single banner of the Sudanese Revolutionary Front (SRF) with a nation-wide agenda.
It was biggest assault yet by the umbrella group of fighters who have vowed to topple President Omar Hassan al-Bashir and end what they see as his elite's stranglehold on the whole country - an accusation he denies.
The government has previously played down the threat posed by the rebels, and called Um Rawaba's attackers "terrorists" holding civilians as "human shields".
NEW FRONTS
Diplomats and analysts said the raid on Um Rawaba appeared to be a bid to stretch Sudan's army ever thinner, across an ever-changing line of battle in Sudan's savannahs and scrublands, rather than an attempted land grab.
"They now feel the government forces are weak, that they can strike anywhere," said Faisal Saleh, a Sudanese journalist.
Bashir, in power since 1989, has been facing small street protests over an economic crisis and also dissent inside the army and his ruling circles.
One of SRF's member groups - Darfur's Justice and Equality Movement (JEM) - has already shown its ability to spread chaos beyond its home territory by launching an unprecedented assault on Khartoum in 2008.
The attack on Um Rawaba, North Kordofan's second biggest city, 500km (300 miles) south of the capital, was much larger than initial reports indicated, officials said.
"They came with 140 cars, each manned with between four and six people," said Um Rawaba commissioner Sharif Fadhil, who, like other local officials, said the situation was now under control.
In the first official toll, Fadhil said 13 civilians and soldiers had been killed. Four other people died in other areas that the rebels had also attacked, officials said.
"Life returned to normality within 48 hours. Now life here will be better than before," said Adam Abdallah, head of a union representing local workers. "The army has spread out everywhere. Citizens stand by the government, army and authorities."
Around 19,000 people in North and South Kordofan have been affected or displaced by the fighting since Saturday, Haroun Abdallah, the government's humanitarian aid commissioner for South Kordofan, said by phone.
Security was tight in Um Rawaba on Thursday. Army trucks with mounted machine-guns were parked in front of all government buildings.
But something like normal life had returned to the streets. Women shopped in the packed market and men drank tea in the shade of makeshift cafes.
Outside the city, a backup transformer at the main power plant had been connected after the old one was set ablaze by the attackers.
"We are happy that power is back and shops open," said Khalid Ezzedin, speaking again in the presence of government minders. "We demand security from the government."

US dithering over Syria


Horrors in Syria expose wishful thinking at the heart of the president’s foreign policy


RECENT history shows that the 21st century is an age of interdependence. That was what Barack Obama told students in Cairo soon after taking office in 2009, in a speech intended to heal rifts with the Muslim world and start restoring America’s image after the mistakes of the Bush years.
America has learned that problems must be tackled with the help of others, Mr Obama humbly reported. He offered examples of global ties that bind. When one nation pursues a nuclear weapon the risks rise for all nations, he said in a nod at Iran. When violent extremists operate in one stretch of mountains, people can be endangered across an ocean. When innocents in Bosnia and Darfur are slaughtered, that is “a stain on our collective conscience”. Interdependence, the president suggested after a pause for applause, is what it means to share the modern world.
Few foreign-policy doctrines survive much contact with reality. But four years later, events are conspiring to undermine Mr Obama’s Cairo pieties with unusual precision. An estimated 70,000 Syrians have already been killed in two years of civil conflict with the Assad regime. Enough of the dead are innocents to stir all but the most brutish conscience. America’s response, though, has been a study in minimalism, an approach set from the top, with Mr Obama worrying that the robust intervention urged by many aides and allies might only make things worse.
By way of a legal and moral backstop, Mr Obama has said for some time that the use of chemical weapons in Syria would cross a “red line” and prompt American action. Yet after reports that sarin, a ghastly nerve agent, had been used on civilians, Mr Obama said on April 30th that he would not rush to judgment. Before making decisions about “America’s national security”, in his revealing phrase, the president called for more clarity about how and by whom such weapons had been used. Then, he declared with lawyerly dispassion, “there are some options that we might not otherwise exercise that we would strongly consider.”
It is true that the president faces only bad choices in Syria. But he is partly to blame. While America and its allies have dithered over calls to arm more moderate wings of the opposition or to impose no-fly zones, the most alarming militants have grown in clout, including fighters who have sworn fealty to al-Qaeda. In a cruel echo of his Cairo speech, Mr Obama must now choose between tolerating conscience-staining massacres and intervening at the risk of empowering violent extremists. Completing his misery, cavilling over chemical weapons in Syria places in peril Mr Obama’s credibility when he warns Iran not to pursue nuclear weapons—a blunder that in turn would raise the nuclear stakes for other countries, just as he observed four years ago.
A standard critique of the president’s foreign policy is that he is cautious to a fault, placing more weight on the costs of action than of inaction. There is something to that. The shadow of Iraq, the conflict that Mr Obama scorned as George W. Bush’s “dumb war”, lies across his decision-making, especially when weighing intelligence about weapons of mass destruction. Libya left its mark, too. Though Mr Obama gave military help to Libyan rebels against Muammar Qaddafi, averting threatened massacres, scars were left by the murder of America’s ambassador and three aides, and reports of loose weapons flooding the wider region.
But caution is not the only problem. When pondering the sad gap between present realities and Mr Obama’s plans for the post-Bush era, what comes to mind is how much wishful thinking was involved. In the light of Syria’s horrors, Mr Obama looks guilty of overconfidence, and of arrogantly believing that by being cleverer than Mr Bush he could avoid traps that plagued him.
The 2009 Cairo speech was part of a series of set-piece foreign policy addresses by Mr Obama. A recurring theme was that Mr Bush, by his clumsiness, led America into unnecessary dilemmas. Outlining counter-terrorism plans, Mr Obama condemned the Bush administration’s “false choice” between constitutionally guaranteed freedoms and security, breezily promising to close the prison camp at Guantánamo Bay (a promise as yet unkept) and adhere to the rule of law. Collecting the Nobel peace prize he was weirdly awarded for getting elected (and for not being Mr Bush), Mr Obama even rejected the need to choose between foreign policy realism and idealism. The trick, he told the assembled worthies of Oslo, is to avoid a clash between the narrow pursuit of interests and an endless campaign to impose American values around the world.
Declaring a choice false does not make it so
Events are now exposing Mr Obama’s hubris. It was smart to re-engage with the world. In his own pithy phrase, a lesson of the Bush years was that “not talking does not work”. But it was cocky to assume that smartness would magically be rewarded. Team Obama insists that virtuous circles lurk behind every corner, removing the need for painful trade-offs. A less bossy America will find it easier to promote core moral beliefs, it is argued. By shunning unwise foreign entanglements, Mr Obama will be free to focus on nation-building at home. Exposed to the tough love of a less attentive America, other nations will have to think harder about their security. Used less, America’s power will be the greater, Mr Obama argued in Cairo, quoting Thomas Jefferson.
Alas, it is not in the gift of politicians—even American presidents—to choose their own trade-offs. True, Syria’s horrors are not Mr Obama’s fault. The blame lies with Bashar Assad and the callous intransigence of such outsiders as Vladimir Putin’s Russia. But the slaughter still mocks Mr Obama’s pieties about interdependence, and his glib plans for win-win diplomacy. Balancing American interests and values is hard. Right now, in Syria, he is advancing neither.

Xi Jinping and the Chinese dream


China's future

The vision of China’s new president should serve his people, not a nationalist state


IN 1793 a British envoy, Lord Macartney, arrived at the court of the Chinese emperor, hoping to open an embassy. He brought with him a selection of gifts from his newly industrialising nation. The Qianlong emperor, whose country then accounted for about a third of global GDP, swatted him away: “Your sincere humility and obedience can clearly be seen,” he wrote to King George III, but we do not have “the slightest need for your country’s manufactures”. The British returned in the 1830s with gunboats to force trade open, and China’s attempts at reform ended in collapse, humiliation and, eventually, Maoism.
China has made an extraordinary journey along the road back to greatness. Hundreds of millions have lifted themselves out of poverty, hundreds of millions more have joined the new middle class. It is on the verge of reclaiming what it sees as its rightful position in the world. China’s global influence is expanding and within a decade its economy is expected to overtake America’s. In his first weeks in power, the new head of the ruling Communist Party, Xi Jinping, has evoked that rise with a new slogan which he is using, as belief in Marxism dies, to unite an increasingly diverse nation. He calls his new doctrine the “Chinese dream” evoking its American equivalent. Such slogans matter enormously in China (see article). News bulletins are full of his dream. Schools organise speaking competitions about it. A talent show on television is looking for “The Voice of the Chinese Dream”.
Countries, like people, should dream. But what exactly is Mr Xi’s vision? It seems to include some American-style aspiration, which is welcome, but also a troubling whiff of nationalism and of repackaged authoritarianism.
The end of ideology
Since the humiliations of the 19th century, China’s goals have been wealth and strength. Mao Zedong tried to attain them through Marxism. For Deng Xiaoping and his successors, ideology was more flexible (though party control was absolute). Jiang Zemin’s theory of the “Three Represents” said the party must embody the changed society, allowing private businessmen to join the party. Hu Jintao pushed the “scientific-development outlook” and “harmonious development” to deal with the disharmony created by the yawning wealth gap.
Now, though, comes a new leader with a new style and a popular photogenic wife. Mr Xi talks of reform; he has launched a campaign against official extravagance. Even short of detail, his dream is different from anything that has come before. Compared with his predecessors’ stodgy ideologies, it unashamedly appeals to the emotions. Under Mao, the party assaulted anything old and erased the imperial past, now Mr Xi’s emphasis on national greatness has made party leaders heirs to the dynasts of the 18th century, when Qing emperors demanded that Western envoys kowtow (Macartney refused).
But there is also plainly practical politics at work. With growth slowing, Mr Xi’s patriotic doctrine looks as if it is designed chiefly to serve as a new source of legitimacy for the Communist Party. It is no coincidence that Mr Xi’s first mention of his dream of “the great revival of the Chinese nation” came in November in a speech at the national museum in Tiananmen Square, where an exhibition called “Road to Revival” lays out China’s suffering at the hands of colonial powers and its rescue by the Communist Party.
Dream a little dream of Xi
Nobody doubts that Mr Xi’s priority will be to keep the economy growing—the country’s leaders talk about it taking decades for their poor nation to catch up with the much richer Americans—and that means opening up China even more. But his dream has two clear dangers.
One is of nationalism. A long-standing sense of historical victimhood means that the rhetoric of a resurgent nation could all too easily turn nasty. As skirmishes and provocations increase in the neighbouring seas (see Banyan), patriotic microbloggers need no encouragement to demand that the Japanese are taught a humiliating lesson. Mr Xi is already playing to the armed forces. In December, on an inspection tour of the navy in southern China, he spoke of a “strong-army dream”. The armed forces are delighted by such talk. Even if Mr Xi’s main aim in pandering to hawks is just to keep them on side, the fear is that it presages a more belligerent stance in East Asia. Nobody should mind a confident China at ease with itself, but a country transformed from a colonial victim to a bully itching to settle scores with Japan would bring great harm to the region—including to China itself.
The other risk is that the Chinese dream ends up handing more power to the party than to the people. In November Mr Xi echoed the American dream, declaring that “To meet [our people’s] desire for a happy life is our mission.” Ordinary Chinese citizens are no less ambitious than Americans to own a home (see article), send a child to university or just have fun (see article). But Mr Xi’s main focus seems to be on strengthening the party’s absolute claim on power. The “spirit of a strong army”, he told the navy, lay in resolutely obeying the party’s orders. Even if the Chinese dream avoids Communist rhetoric, Mr Xi has made it clear that he believes the Soviet Union collapsed because the Communist Party there strayed from ideological orthodoxy and rigid discipline. “The Chinese dream”, he has said, “is an ideal. Communists should have a higher ideal, and that is Communism.”
A fundamental test of Mr Xi’s vision will be his attitude to the rule of law. The good side of the dream needs it: the economy, the happiness of his people and China’s real strength depend on arbitrary power being curtailed. But corruption and official excess will be curbed only when the constitution becomes more powerful than the party. This message was spelled out in an editorial in a reformist newspaper on January 1st, entitled “The Dream of Constitutionalism”. The editorial called for China to use the rule of law to become a “free and strong country”. But the censors changed the article at the last minute and struck out its title. If that is the true expression of Mr Xi’s dream, then China still has a long journey ahead.

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Morning Social Media Newsfeed Tuesday, April 30, 2013


mediabistro.com <mailer@email.mediabistro.com>
5:07 AM (2 hours ago)
to me
SocialTimes


Market your business to millions. Join our online Facebook Marketing Intensive.

advertisement


 Click here to receive the Morning Social Media Newsfeed via email.

FoursquareWith its Future on the Line, Foursquare Readies Ad Retargeting and In-App Ads (SocialTimes)
Foursquare is looking for advertisers to participate in its efforts to retarget ads to Web users based on their check-ins and to serve up interstitial ads in its mobile apps, according to a leaked pitch deck for advertisers obtained by Gawker's Valley Wag. Foursquare's latest round of funding was in loans, rather than outright investment, demonstrating its investors' impatience with the company's failure to generate revenue. CNET Foursquare CEO Dennis Crowley wants to dismiss worries that the startup isn't growing, saying that all important metrics are rising about 10 percent to 30 percent from month to month. Crowley, who also is a co-founder of the check-in and local search app, noted that Foursquare "doesn't talk about growth numbers that much," but the company pays attention to the number of active users, signups, check-ins, people using search and other metrics, and all are rising, he said.SFGate Crowley noted that March was the company's highest revenue-generating month yet, and that it's regularly signing six-figure deals with advertisers and merchants. He wouldn't comment on 2013 revenue, merely stating that the company is on track to hit an aggressive goal. Street Fight 
Foursquare capped off its nearly yearlong transition into a local discovery service earlier this month, releasing a major update to its mobile application that brought search features to the forefront of the service. The update put the New York-based startup on a collision course with the publicly traded Yelp, pitting the two companies in an indirect (if not lopsided) battle over the future of local discovery. VentureBeat Foursquare's plight contrasts strongly with the success of shopping app Shopkick, which is pulling in cash in ways that most location-based mobile apps - including Foursquare - have so far been unable to. The app, which rewards people for shopping in certain stores, helped Shopkick's partners make $200 million last year.

Android's Google Now Feature Comes to iPhone (The Wall Street Journal/Digits)
With an update to its search app, Google's intelligent search system Google Now is now available for the iPhone and iPad. It doesn't have as deep of an integration with the operating system like it does on Android, but this Google Now version does offer a taste of one of the smartest features on Android. The Huffington Post Google Now's invasion of Siri's turf marks Google's latest attempt to lure iPhone and iPad users away from a service that Apple built into its own devices. Google quickly won over millions of iPhone users in December when it released a mapping application to replace the navigation system that Apple dumped when it redesigned iOS last fall. CNET Unlike Google Now on Android, which you can start using as long as your device is running Android 4.1 or later, the Google Now app on iOS will require you to log in to your Google account first. But the defining features of Google Now, the voice recognition and the predictive search, remain intact.

Jason Collins Thanks Fans on Twitter After Coming Out (Mashable)
Jason Collins was the talk of Twitter on Monday after coming out and becoming the first openly gay active athlete in a major American sport. He dominated Twitter's list of worldwide trends.

jobs of the dayTechnical Account Manager
Amazon
Seattle, WA
Social Media Coordinator
Liberty Science Center
Jersey City, NJ
Sr. Game Designer
Disney Interactive | Playdom
Palo Alto, CA
Post your job here


9 Social Media Tips for Freelancers from Columbia's Sree Sreenivasan (SocialTimes)
Columbia University's first chief digital officer Sree Sreenivasan @sree provided a slew of social media advice to freelancers at ASJA 2013. Here are just a few of his tips.

Weather Company Unveils Three New Web Series, Offers 'Four-Screen' Ad Opportunity (paidContent)
The Weather Company, eager to expand beyond its usual fare of snow and storms, announced three new original Web series on Monday that will feature athlete amputees, virus pandemics and disaster survivors. On the social media front, the Weather Company has been creating personalized products like custom Twitter forecasts and, as an executive described Monday, a "social emergency network" that can let people use Facebook to warn loved ones in a given region about an impending weather apocalypse.

Facebook Nixes Option Allowing Users to See Only Posts from Friends on a Page (AllFacebook)
Previously, users could visit Facebook pages and choose to see posts from their friends. However, as sister site Inside Facebook discovered recently, that option is no longer there. Now, users can only see posts by the pages and posts by fans, but not posts by their friends.

Mediabistro online course
Social Media 101
Social Media Training for Beginners
May 2 - 30 | Online
New to social media? Learn how to develop a social media plan based on your business goals and create meaningful content for your online audience. Register Toay.





Twitter and Comedy Central Kick Off 5-Day #ComedyFest with Mel Brooks' First Tweet (The Next Web)
Twitter and Comedy Central have kicked off a five-day experimental online comedy festival that will take place on Twitter and Vine, beginning first with a live-streamed event featuring Mel Brooks, the "2,000 Year Old Man," as he signs up for a Twitter account with the help of Carl Reiner and Judd Apatow. Brooks and Reiner made literal comedic history in the 1960s with their 2,000 Year Old Man sketches.

Twitter Ads App Throws its Neck on Chopping Block (AllTwitter)
Miles Recny admits that his app, Followgen, directly cannibalizes Twitter's ads revenue model and does so on Twitter's very own platform. It seems he's trying to prevent his app's inevitable demise - or, at the very least, he's attempting to will it to happen with some measure of predictability (one of those).

Instagram Reverses Ban on Account (The Verge)
Instagram drew attention to itself this weekend for banning an account that published user-submitted pictures of everyday objects that merely resembled penises. The account, called @thatlookslikeadick, was inspired by a widely-circulated picture of the Curiosity rover's tire-tracks that looked like a phallus.

WebMediaBrands event
AllFacebook Marketing Conference
Facebook Marketing Immersion
June 5 | San Francisco
Learn the tricks of the social media trade with digital media and marketing experts at Jack Daniel's, Starwood Hotels & Resorts, and Toyota. Register now!



Click here to read more on SocialTimes, and here to get RSS feeds for updates throughout the day. Subscribe to our Daily Newsfeed Email and see all our blogs at Mediabistro.
SocialTimes Needs You! Send us your story tips, job changes, insider gossip, and all that other good stuff:socialtimescom@mediabistro.com

To learn about advertising or other creative partnerships, contact Dave Arganbright at (212) 547-7931 or via email.
You are receiving this email at biginla2@gmail.com because you subscribed at Mediabistro for our Daily SocialTimes Feed service. Please add mailer@email.mediabistro.com to your Address Book to ensure delivery of this email (how do I do this?).
Stop Receiving this Email | Start Receiving this Email | Send Feedback

Mediabistro
475 Park Avenue South | New York | NY | 10016
Mediabistro is a division of WebMediaBrands Inc.

Monday, April 29, 2013

US Tax policy: Sweet land of subsidy


The downturn has forced states to be savvier and more careful about providing tax incentives to business


ON NOVEMBER 14th 2012, before audience of elected officials and assorted local dignitaries, voestalpine Metal Forming, a division of an Austrian steel company, broke ground on a manufacturing facility in Bartow County, around 50 miles (80km) north-west of Atlanta. Voestalpine supplies parts to European carmakers, and hopes to expand further. Mercedes-Benz has its only American plant near Tuscaloosa, Alabama, while Volkswagen has one in Chattanooga, Tennessee, just over the Georgia border. Car-manufacturing factories dot the south-east, a region of low-tax states without strong unions and offering relatively cheap land. Voestalpine looked at many sites across the region, and finally narrowed the contenders down to three states.
Georgia boasts the world’s busiest airport, America’s fourth-busiest container port, several interstate highways and a well-respected workforce-training programme. To sweeten the deal, however, the state’s economic development team gave voestalpine an array of tax credits and incentives: $3.3m in job-creation credits and $1.4m in port-tax credits over five years, $4m in sales-tax exemptions on machinery and equipment, $3m in local-tax abatements and a grant of $275,000 towards site developments—in all, over $14m in credits and cost exemptions.
If that seems steep, consider that Voestalpine will invest $62m in the facility, which is scheduled to open later this year. Not including the jobs and the economic activity generated during its construction, it will eventually employ 220 people directly and could generate hundreds more jobs for its suppliers and vendors. Those 220 jobs will pay employees an average annual salary between $30,000 and $40,000—right around the Bartow County average of $37,000 a year, and particularly welcome these days, when the county’s unemployment rate stands at 9%, well above the national average of 7.6%. Much of that money will find its way back into the community as employees buy houses, food, cars and so forth—and as they spend they will pay sales and property taxes, which means more government revenue and so more money for social services.
If voestalpine fails to meet 80% or better of its promised investment and job-creation targets in five years, Georgia can claw back whatever portion of the $14m in credits and grants has not been claimed or spent. Chris Cummiskey, who heads Georgia’s Department of Economic Development, says that companies such as voestalpine “are putting far more into the community than they are taking out”.
Not everyone agrees. Opposition to incentives is a rare issue that can unite progressives and “tea-party” types. Greg LeRoy, who heads an economic-development watchdog group called Good Jobs First, suggests that states would be better off making investments that benefit everyone, rather than showering big companies with dollars. He calls subsidies aimed at luring or, worse, retaining companies that say they are thinking of moving (see chart) “a race to the bottom” that “wastes a lot of money on a microscopic fraction of employees”. Instead he suggests that governments should fund “training programmes, cluster training, investments in infrastructure or fibre-optic networks or [school] education. These are much safer investments…benefiting lots of different employers.” Mr Cummiskey believes that given Georgia’s infrastructure, even with no incentives, “We’d pick up most of the business in the south-east.”
That is easy to say from a comfortable perch in a big, rich city such as Atlanta. But incentives can give scrappier, hungrier places a way to compete for business. They keep dominant cities from getting too comfortable. They help businesses keep costs down and hedge their expansion risks. The cash crunch that followed the downturn led some states to spend more on economic development in order to lure businesses. It has led others to save precious funds by tightening economic-development budgets. Putting even a rough dollar figure on the number of incentives offered is difficult, but all states and many cities and counties have them, and they have become an accepted and largely beneficial aspect of competition.
They take a variety of forms: credits for creating jobs, taxpayer-funded workforce training, property-tax abatements, assistance with land acquisition (land is often just given away) and site development, credits against expenses for research and development, sales-tax refunds on machinery or energy used in manufacturing, credits for redeveloping brownfields or opening a business in a poor district.
Some are statutory; they are available to any company that meets a predetermined requirement. The $3.3m in job-creation credits that voestalpine will receive, for instance, comes from a credit available to any company in Georgia that creates jobs in one of seven sectors, including manufacturing. A company gets $3,000 per job per year for five years as a credit against its total tax liability. Voestalpine’s port-tax credits are also available to any company in Georgia that increases imports or exports through Georgia’s ports by at least 10% over the previous year. Around half of all American states have some sort of job-creation tax credits. Some target wages, as Georgia’s does; others target types of businesses: in 2010 California and Connecticut both enacted credits for small businesses that hire full-time workers.
Others, such as the relatively small $275,000 that went toward voestalpine’s site development, are discretionary, meaning they go to specific companies for specific purposes—most often to large companies relocating or expanding in a state. The largest source of discretionary funds is probably the Texas Enterprise Fund (TEF), which Rick Perry, the governor, created in 2003. Texas calls this a “deal-closing” fund, critics a slush fund for the well-connected; either way, it provides grants that have ranged between $194,000 and $50m to companies choosing between a site in Texas and one in another state. Companies must promise to hire a lot of people (at least 75 in cities and 25 in rural areas) at wages above the county average. Since 2004 the TEF has dispersed $487.4m. Texas also offers grants to technology companies through its Texas Emerging Technology Fund, which has given nearly $195m to 137 businesses since 2005.
Texas’s free hand has inspired copycats: all its neighbours now have discretionary deal-closing funds, as do several other states. They have come into vogue even as cash grants have generally grown scarcer. Companies may prefer cash grants to help them hedge risks and defray costs during a major expansion or those tenuous first few years, but in recent times states have tended to prefer credits and abatements, which have little or no upfront cost and have impacts that can be spread over several years.
The downturn has also led to demands for greater accountability for recipients of incentives and greater scrutiny from state legislatures. Many states now have clawback provisions written into their incentives. A 2012 study by the Pew Centre on the States found that (only) 13 states rigorously assessed their economic-development incentives, and used the results of those assessments to inform policy decisions (see map). Without such measures costs can balloon. Louisiana, for instance, brought in an extraction-tax exemption for horizontal drilling in 1994, when that was a newish technology. In 2007 it cost the state $285,000. By 2010 horizontal drilling had become a common method of getting natural-gas deposits from the Haynesville Shale in northern Louisiana, and the exemption cost the state $239m. Such scrutiny may have helped inspire the welcome trend away from film-tax credits, which have limited lasting effect; the number of states offering them fell from 40 in 2010 to 34 in 2012, though that is still a lot more than four in 2001.
Even supporters admit that there is no simple way to determine how effective incentives are. Take Texas. According to the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, between June 2009 and June 2011 the state was responsible for nearly half of all jobs created in America. How much of that is due to the generous incentives it offers, and how much to other factors? Texas, after all, is a state where union closed-shops are banned, and with a lot of cheap land; a company could relocate there from Chicago, Boston or New York and come out ahead on land and labour costs alone.
A study by Angelou Economics, a consultancy headed by Angelos Angelou, a former vice-president of economic development for the Greater Austin Chamber of Commerce, in April 2012 found job growth correlated less with the amount of incentives states offer than with rates of entrepreneurship, retention of young professionals and overall business climate. States with an ageing population and high corporate taxes, such as Maine, may need to be more generous with incentives than young, low-tax states such as Georgia or Texas. Some may not like it, but brisk interstate competition is far better than none.