American student Amanda Knox served four years in jail after her initial conviction for murder before being released on appeal then acquitted American student Amanda Knox served four years in jail after her initial conviction for murder before being released on appeal then acquittedAFP/File
Europe's top human rights court said Thursday Italy failed to provide adequate legal representation for Amanda Knox, an American student acquitted in 2015 of the gruesome killing of her British housemate.
It ordered the Italian authorities to pay 18,400 euros ($20,900) in damages and legal costs.
ADVERTISING
Knox accused the Italian police of threats and violence during questioning over the 2007 murder, when she was denied both a lawyer and a professional interpreter.
The American exchange student served four years in prison after her initial conviction for participating in the killing of Meredith Kercher, before being released on appeal and then definitively acquitted.
Kercher's body was found on November 2, 2007, in the apartment she and Knox shared in Perugia, where they were both foreign exchange students.
The case at the European Court of Human Rights concerned Knox's claim about ill-treatment during overnight questioning by police on November 6.
The court said she claimed she was slapped on the head twice, and forced to speak despite being exhausted and unable to show discernment or willpower.
Knox also said she was not assisted by an independent and professional interpreter, but only a police employee who acted instead as a "mediator" who encouraged her to "imagine hypothetical scenarios".
During the questioning she accused her former manager at a pub of murdering Kercher, who was later released without charge, prompting prosecutors to accuse Knox of making a "malicious accusation."
The court said the Italian authorities had improperly denied access to a lawyer and failed to assess the conduct of the police interpreter, which had "compromised the fairness of the proceedings as a whole."
But it said it had found no evidence of inhuman or degrading treatment during her questioning.
ROME - Nigerian migrants who survived a deadly sea crossing last year filed a lawsuit against Italy for violating their rights by supporting Libya’s efforts to return them to North Africa, their lawyers said on Tuesday.
Violeta Moreno-Lax of the Global Legal Action Network looks on during a news conference at the Foreign Press association in Rome, Italy, May 8, 2018. REUTERS/Max Rossi
Seventeen plaintiffs petitioned the European Court of Human Rights last week, Violeta Moreno-Lax, a legal advisor for the Global Legal Action Network, told reporters. She was among four lawyers and several humanitarian groups involved in the case.
The migrants say Italy violated multiple articles of the European Convention on Human Rights, including that people not be subjected to torture, held in slavery, or have their lives put in danger.
The United Nations, rights groups and news organizations say migrants face these conditions in Libya.
This is the first lawsuit to be filed against Italy for its decision to back the Libyan Coast Guard. The country lost a case in the same court in 2012 for directly handing over migrants intercepted at sea to Libyan authorities.
The legal process can take up to three years but should the migrants win they can be awarded damages, and Italy would be forced to abandon its policy of equipping, training and coordinating the Libyan Coast Guard, Moreno-Lax said.
“Using the Libyan Coast Guard as a proxy to turn back migrant boats is just a new way of camouflaging (Italy’s) strategy of fighting irregular migration in the Mediterranean by trapping them in what the Italian Foreign Ministry itself has qualified as ‘the hell’ of Libya,” Moreno-Lax said.
The lawsuit highlights a stand-off between humanitarian groups seeking to save lives on the open seas and Italian authorities backed by the European Union who are trying to stop people from making the dangerous crossing in the first place.
ADVERTISING
A spokesman for Italy’s Interior Ministry, which has spearheaded the policy, had no immediate comment.
Libyan naval spokesman Ayoub Qassem said the coast guard does its job within the terms agreed with Italy.
“Regarding the abuse and violations against the migrants, these are all considered as individual acts ... We can’t say Libyan state institutions commit these acts,” Qassem said.
SEA CROSSINGS DOWN
Italy has supplied Libya with seven refurbished vessels so far, and three more have been promised, while the EU has trained about 190 Libyan coastguards.
Forensic Oceanography researcher Charles Heller looks on during a news conference at the Foreign Press association in Rome, Italy, May 8, 2018. REUTERS/Max Rossi
Italy is also coordinating communications with the Libyan Coast Guard about possible boats in distress, according to court documents filed recently in Sicily.
Between 2014 and 2017, more than 600,000 migrants arrived on Italian shores, but crossings have fallen dramatically since Italy and Libya signed a memorandum of understanding aimed at stemming the migration flow in February of last year.
During the first five months of this year, arrivals from Libya fell more than 80 percent versus last year to 6,700 during, official data show. Over the same period, the Libyan Coast Guard intercepted almost 6,000 migrants and refugees. In 2017, the Libyans turned back almost 19,000.
Two of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit were intercepted and returned to Libya. They said they were held for two months in a detention center where they were subjected to beatings and extortion, and where even basic food and healthcare was not provided, before returning to Nigeria with the International Organization for Migration.
All the plaintiffs were rescued at sea on Nov. 6 as at least 20 migrants drowned when a part of their rubber boat deflated.
German humanitarian ship Sea Watch 3 rescued 59 people that day and collected the body of a small child, all of whom were brought to Italy.
The Libyan naval vessel, which had been donated by Italy and was operated mainly by a crew trained by the EU, returned 47 to Libya. In a video shot by Sea Watch, the Libyans are seen beating the migrants they intercepted with a rope, and the vessel then speeds off with a man clinging to the side.
Among the survivors returned to Libya, two were subsequently sold to a smuggler and tortured with electricity in an attempt to extort money from their families, said Charles Heller, co-founder of the Forensic Oceanography project, which prepared a report to support the lawsuit.
The European Court of Justice rules that a ban is not discriminatory if it meets certain conditions
EMPLOYERS are entitled to forbid their Muslim staff from wearing headscarves as long as it is part of a consistent practice of banning the display of religious or ideological symbols, and not a one-off action aimed at satisfying the demands of a particular client.
That was the main thrust of a decision issued today by the European Court of Justice (ECJ), a Luxembourg-based tribunal whose job it is to interpret and uphold the laws of the European Union. “An internal rule…which prohibits the visible wearing of any political, philosophical or religious sign does not constitute direct discrimination,” the court said.
The ECJ judges were looking into the cases of a Belgian woman who was fired from her job as a receptionist at a security company after she started wearing a headscarf, and of a French IT consultant who was told to remove her scarf after a client complained, and then dismissed when she declined.
In both cases, the ECJ suggested that national courts needed to investigate further to establish whether the women had been discriminated against. In the Belgian case, the court recommended working out if there might have been a simpler solution such as transferring the employee to a role where she was not in contact with the public. Regarding the French consultant, it considered it necessary to establish whether the disciplinary action was purely a response to the client’s whim (which appeared to be the case and would be insufficient grounds for a dismissal) or a legitimate consequence of a broader policy. Taken as a whole, today’s decision upheld the right of employers to enforce ideological neutrality in the workplace as long as it was done fairly and consistently.
This marks a contrast with the thinking of America’s Supreme Court, which in 2015 vindicated a Muslim woman who had been turned down for a job by the clothing chain Abercrombie and Fitch on the grounds that her headscarf was out of step with the look the company was promoting. Since 1964, American civil-rights legislation has told employers to provide “reasonable accommodation” of their workers’ religious needs, unless it would be unbearably burdensome to do so. Today's decision also reflected a more secularist spirit than did one by the European Court of Human Rights in 2013, which upheld the right of a Christian woman to wear a discreet cross with her British Airways uniform.
Today’s judgement might look like a careful, Solomonic piece of jurisprudence designed to take the sting out of a contentious issue by steering a course down the middle. But so charged is the political atmosphere in Europe these days that it is likely to have the very opposite effect.
The decision was instantly deplored by Islamic and some other religious groups, as well as some secular human-rights campaigners including Amnesty International, for legitimising discrimination. No less speedily, it was welcomed by some of the resurgent forces on Europe’s cultural and political right, including Germany’s anti-immigrant "Alternative for Germany" party.
The ruling does indeed appear to be good news for Marine Le Pen, the French presidential candidate who would like to see all conspicuous religious symbols removed from public spaces. It should also please the right-wing standard-bearer in this week’s Dutch elections, Geert Wilders, who has listed the headscarf as one of the many manifestations of Islam that he would like to see much less of. Francois Fillon, the centre-right (and culturally conservative) candidate in the French presidential race, was among the first public figures to welcome the ruling.
A more liberal-minded and middle-of-the-road defence of the decision came from Britain's National Secular Society, whose campaigns director Stephen Evans said that for bosses, "religous and political neutrality is a perfectly reasonable aim." Meanwhile intense Muslim unhappiness over the ruling was articulated by the Islamic Human Rights Commission, a London-based lobby group, where a spokeswoman said: “This gives legal cover to what is essentially an ongoing hate campaign to make Muslims second-class citizens in Europe. It will only increase feelings of marginalisation and disenfranchisement in Muslim communities.”
The ECJ's ruling is a call to apply a single, transparent rule to people of all creeds and cultures. But religious and cultural symbols seem to be an area where nobody can agree on what "neutrality" really means.